Highlanders Clip Eagles for Second Time this Season

On a snowy, below freezing night in front of a rather sparse crowd at the Highlander's gym Thursday evening, Webster played what appeared to be a less than enthusiastic game against the Braxton County Eagles, but won easily 56 to 38.

Except for early in the first quarter, Webster led the entire game. At the end of the first quarter, the Highlanders held a 16 to 6 lead, and led at halftime 27 to 18. In the third quarter, Webster seemed to play in slow motion and at one point allowed Braxton to creep to within 5 points, but the quarter ended with the Highlanders leading 39 to 27. Webster finally broke the game wide open by outscoring the Eagles 17 to 11 in the fourth quarter for the final tally of 56 to 38.

After the game, Assistant Coach Eddie Mazzella best summed up Webster's performance.  "You have to realize we haven't played since the 22nd. We beat Roane County last Tuesday. We had four days we couldn't practice because of snow days, last Thursday, Friday, Saturday, and Sunday. We had three days of practice this week and we had some pretty good practices, but when you don't play it's not the same thing. So, we were kind of going through the motions--played good defense, but the offense wasn't quite there," he said.

Mazzella also noted that this is the second time Webster has beaten Braxton this year. He noted that it was a big game because it kept the Highlanders undefeated among the possible teams that Webster could face in the section playoffs, meaning that the sectional playoffs would be played at Webster if they make a run in the playoffs. "We still have a ways to go, we're 11 and 2, and we just got to keep going," he said.

Brett Morris led the Highlanders with 21 points, 8 assists, 5 rebounds, 4 steals, and 1 blocked shot. Dalton Davis showed once again he can be a force to be reckoned with as he poured in 10 points,   and he had 2 rebounds and 2 blocked shots. Others on the stat sheet playing for Webster included: Hunter Given, 7 points, 8 rebounds, 5 steals, 1 assist, 1 blocked shot; Hunter Williams, 6 points, 1 blocked shot; Logan Taylor, 5 points, 4 rebounds; Jake Thayer, 4 points, 2 rebounds; Stephen Cogar, 3 points, 5 rebounds, 1 assist; Guy Cowger, 3 steals, 2 rebounds, 2 assists; Drew Green, 1 blocked shot, 1 assist.

As a team, Webster made 18 of 42 shots (42%), including 5 of ten 3 point shots (50%), and made 15 of 26 free throws (57%).

Class AA Webster will host the Class AAA Shady Spring Tigers on Friday evening, weather permitting. Shady Spring has played a tough schedule and currently sports an 8 win, 6 loss record, and they feature first team all-state player Chase Connor with a good supporting cast. 

Cole Shannon McCourt Pleads Guilty to Four Felonies

A Webster Springs man entered guilty pleas to four felony drug offenses today before Circuit Judge Jack Alsop.

Cole Shannon McCourt

Cole Shannon McCourt, age 56, pleaded guilty to one count of Possession with Intent to Deliver Methamphetamine, one count of Possession with Intent to Deliver Marijuana, one count of Manufacturing Marijuana, and one count of Conspiracy to Possess with the Intent to Deliver Marijuana and/or Methamphetamine. As part of his plea agreement, McCourt admitted that he has a prior felony drug offense that would subject him to double penalties on his current offenses. Based on his pleas and prior offense, McCourt faces a maximum possible sentence of not less than seven but not more than 35 years in prison.

McCourt also gave up any interest he has in $18,277.00 in cash seized from him when he was arrested. As part of the plea agreement, McCourt admitted that the $18,277.00 was "drug money." Prosecuting Attorney Dwayne Vandevender has already filed a forfeiture action regarding that money as well as property on which the drugs were found.

According to the original criminal complaint filed against McCourt, State Police officers on August 29, 2012 were conducting an aerial search for marijuana in the County. The State Police helicopter crew observed marijuana growing behind McCourt's residence at 665 Elk River Road, Webster Springs, West Virginia. State Police officer Bostic then received consent from McCourt to search his residence and a camp (the camp was located about four miles down along the Elk River from Webster Springs). Police found six marijuana plants at the residence, seven marijuana plants at the camp, one container of methamphetamine in the attic of the camp, one container of methamphetamine hidden in the woods behind the camp that McCourt admitted he had concealed, and $18,277.00 in cash. Bostic then recorded a statement from McCourt and McCourt's son that they had conspired together to grow the marijuana and had the intent to sell both the marijuana and methamphetamine.

McCourt remains incarcerated at the Central Regional Jail pending a pre-sentence report by the probation office and sentencing by Judge Alsop.

Erbacon Arson Case Bound Over to Grand Jury; Bond for Collins Lowered

Blake Marshall Collins

The arson case against Blake Marshall Collins is now bound over to the Webster County Grand Jury after Collins waived his right to a preliminary hearing in Magistrate Court yesterday.

Collins and his attorney, Paul Williams of Summersville, signed a written waiver of the preliminary hearing before Magistrate Richard Roberston on January 30, 2013. In addition, Magistrate Robertson lowered the bond for Collins to $100,000.00, by either posting cash or a surety bond from a bondsman, with a condition of home confinement if the bond is posted. Prosecuting Attorney Dwayne Vandevender did not object to the bond being lowered.

Previously, on December 21, 2012, Magistrate Robertson continued the preliminary hearing at Collins' request until the January 30, 2013 date and lowered the bond set by Magistrate John Stone from $500,000.00 to $250,000.00, again without objection from the Prosecutor.

Before Collins waived the preliminary hearing on January 30, 2013, the Commentator has been informed that Collins and his attorney met privately with the Prosecutor and Fire Marshalls for about a half hour to discuss evidence the Fire Marshalls provided as discovery in the case.

The purpose of a preliminary hearing is to determine whether or not there is probable cause to believe that a defendant committed a felony or felonies. By waiving the hearing, Collins in effect did not contest a probable cause finding. He also gave up his right to testify at the preliminary hearing, his right to call witnesses, and his right to cross-examine witnesses that may have been called by the State.

Video of Wednesday's Storm When It Hit Webster Springs

Video of the leading edge of the storm that hit Webster Springs at about 11:10 a.m. on January 30, 2013--taken from the third floor of the Webster County Courthouse.

Brace for Impact

Above: Regional radar from Intellicast.com as of 9:30 a.m. on January 30, 2013.

Flashback: Rock Slide Reveals Fossil Treasure

Above: Rock slide in May, 1992 on Route 15 just below Guardian.

Back in May of 1992, after a very wet Spring, a large section of a cliff of rocks collapsed onto State Route 15 next to the Holly River just below the town of Guardian, blocking both lanes of traffic for several hours. One lane was reopened within four hours and both lanes were cleared by the end of the following day.

What was most unusual about this rock slide was the large number of people who visited the site over the next few days picking through and taking home pieces of rock from the slide. Further analysis of the rocks from the slide revealed why: an approximately one foot layer of petrified vegetative material and animal fossils could be found in that reddish-brown layer of rock. A "treasure trove" of fossils of plants, trees, branches, snakes, fish, slugs, and other like species were preserved in the rocks, some of which is shown in the photos below.

Above: Large 4 foot wide by 3 foot high rock taken from the "fossil layer" of the rock slide.

Above: Some closeups of the fossils found on the large rock above.

More Strange Weather for Webster County Predicted

Above: Current national radar from Intellicast.com as of 5:45 p.m. on January 29, 2013. An unusual cold front is expected to cause potentially severe thunderstorms for Webster County on Wednesday, with as much as 1.5 inches of rain during a brief six hour period. A local flash flood watch has also been issued and the warm temperatures will quickly disappear. After this storm passes by, Webster residents can expect much colder temperatures for the rest of the week, with snow back in the forecast for Thursday through Saturday.

Associated Press Poll Ranks Webster 6th in Class AA

The Associated Press released today its rankings of the top ten teams in Class AA high school boys' basketball.  Webster inched up from 7th to 6th in the rankings. Here are the top ten teams in the AP poll, followed by the team's record:

1. Bluefield, 10-1
2. Poca, 13-1
3. Wyoming East, 10-2
4. Fairmont Senior, 11-3
5. Robert C. Byrd, 9-3
6. Webster County, 10-2
7. Tolsia, 9-6
8. Westside, 9-5*
8. Scott    10-6*
10. Roane County, 11-3

Others receiving votes: Bridgeport, Liberty Raleigh, North Marion, Mount View.

*Westside and Scott were tied for 8th in the poll.

This week, the Highlanders will host Braxton County on Thursday, January 31, 2013 (7:30 p.m. varsity tip off), and they will host Shady Spring on Friday, February 1, 2013 (7:30 p.m. varsity tip off). The following week, the Highlanders will play Liberty-Raleigh twice in a re-shuffled schedule. First, Webster will travel to Liberty-Raleigh on Wednesday, February 6, 2013, in a game to be played at the Beckley-Raleigh County Armory, also known as the Beckley Convention Center. Then, the Highlanders will host Liberty-Raleigh on Saturday, February 9, 2013, with the varsity tip off at 2:30 p.m. (JV tip off at 1:00 p.m.).

The 9 win, 5 loss Lady Highlanders are in action tonight at Richwood and return home Tuesday to host Braxton County and Wednesday to host Fayetteville.

Fire Damages Hamer Lumber Mill

Damages caused by a Sunday evening fire at the Jim C. Hamer lumber mill at Curtin were kept to a minimum due to the quick response of the Webster Springs Fire Department.

According to Webster Springs Deputy Fire Chief Donnie McCourt, firemen from the department had the fire suppressed within just a few minutes of their arrival on scene at the lumber mill. Cleanup of smoldering saw dust and similar wood items kept the firefighters on scene for another hour and a half. McCourt said that Hamer employees discovered the fire on the "green chain line" of the mill's operations, and those employees first attempted to suppress the fire with fire extinguishers before calling for help.

The mill was not in operation at the time, and Hamer's Manager, Jim Stout, said the Hamer employees who discovered the fire were night watchmen. Both Stout and McCourt said there were no injuries due to the fire, and that it appeared the source of the fire was electrical in nature. "Most of the damage was to electrical lines related to the conveyor, with some structural damage to wood trusses and a wall," McCourt said.

The "green chain line" is at the end of the mill's operation after the wood is cut and graded, just before it is stacked for drying or shipment. Stout said that he expects the green chain line to be repaired and back up and running within a day. He estimated damages for parts to fix the line at a few thousand dollars. Stout said while that part of the mill would not be operating Monday, Hamer employees are still working in other areas of the mill.

McCourt said that his fire department sent two engines, one tanker, and one ladder truck to the fire, with about 20 firefighters on scene from the Webster Springs outfit. The Cowen Fire Department, in accordance with a mutual aid agreement with Webster Springs, sent one tanker to the scene, and one engine truck was sent to the Webster Springs Fire Department to be on standby in case of another fire outbreak. Cowen had at least four firefighters at the scene.

Crime Rate Declines Considerably in Webster County

The crime rate in Webster County is down in a big way according to statistics maintained by the West Virginia Division of Justice and Community Services.

From 2007 to 2011, total serious crime offenses dropped from 257 to 166. Of those crimes, violent crimes have dropped from 36 in 2007 to just 12 in 2011. Serious property crime offenses have also dropped from 79 in 2007 to 58 in 2011.

A review of these statistics show a strong connection in the drop in the crime rate with the election of the current Magistrates who took office January 1, 2009. In 2007 and 2008, before the current Magistrates took office, violent crimes were double what they have been in 2009, 2010, and 2011. Serious property crimes have declined by one-third since the current Magistrates took office.

Total overall serious crimes has declined since 2007, as follows: In 2007, 257 serious offenses were reported; in, 2008, 232 serious offenses were reported; in 2009, after the first full year the current Magistrates were in office, the number of total serious offenses dropped considerably to 178; in 2010, the number dropped even more to 119; and in 2011, the number jumped back up to 166, but still well below the 2007 and 2008 numbers.

The WV Division of Justice and Community Services collects the data from the counties and provides the data on their website. The website provides this explanation of the data reporting system:

The National Incident-Based Reporting System (NIBRS) is the modernized version of the Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) Program utilized by law enforcement since 1930.  Details about every single crime occurrence are recorded in NIBRS as opposed to the summary counts available through the UCR.  WV was the sixteenth state to receive NIBRS certification by the FBI and began only accepting data in the WVIBRS format as of January 1, 1999.  WV is currently one of only a few states that are 100% represented by Incident-Based Reporting. 

NIBRS and WVIBRS collect information on every single crime incident and arrest within 22 crime categories.  Incident, offense, property, victim, offender, and arrestee data are collected in this dynamic system.  The SAC receives calendar year WVIBRS data files from the state repository collected and maintained by the WV State Police Uniform Crime Reporting Section.  Calendar year data are extracted from the WVIBRS with approximately four months lag time.

To access the full statistics for Webster County for the period 2007 to 2011, please click on this link:

http://www.djcs.wv.gov/Pages/county-details.aspx?County=webster

New Design for the Commentator

We have listened to a number of readers about our layout and design and we have decided to make a few changes, primarily in color backgrounds to make the Commentator easier on the eyes to read.  We are keeping with our red, black, and white Webster County theme, but to a lesser degree. We hope you find our changes for the better.

Webster County Property Taxes Will Increase Next Year

Webster County landowners will face a hike in real property taxes but it will not occur until next year.

This article will address the reasons why and how a property tax hike will occur.

In recent years, the County is spending considerably more than it takes in. From 2008 to 2012, revenue has declined $509,968.40, while spending has increased $1,192,276.14. In the past fiscal year alone (from July 1, 2011 to June 30, 2012), the County spent over $800,000.00 more than it took in. Because the County has certain financial reserves to cover that $800,000.00 deficit, all bills have been paid to date. 

However, when the current fiscal year ends on June 30, 2013, the County will have depleted all of its reserves. In order to keep the next fiscal year's budget balanced, the County will have to either make certain cuts or raise taxes to cover the shortfall. Declining coal severance tax revenues, substantially increased Regional Jail fees, and ballooning employee related expenses have all contributed to the budget mess (see links at end of article).

To fix the budget problem, in addition to some spending cuts that could cover part of the deficit, the County will be faced with raising property taxes.

Earlier this month, new Assessor Max Cochran published a notice that said: "I am notifying all real property owners of Webster County that for Tax Year 2013 all real property will be assessed at 60% of its current market value. This may result in a general increase in the assessed value of your real property, including natural resource property, by 10% or more. This is the average overall increase but individual assessment increases may vary." The notice goes on to say that "if you disagree with the value of your real property, you may appeal the valuation to the County Commission..."

Does that mean that Assessor Max Cochran is raising your property taxes this year?

Answer: No. Not this year. But next year? Yes, but only because the law requires it.

The notice published by Cochran is required by law and simply tells property owners that their property is already being assessed at 60% of its value, and that if you disagree with the current assessment of your property as its value is already listed on the property books, you can dispute the value before the County Commission. These assessed values will remain the same when your tax bill comes out in August of this year. In other words, Max Cochran is not doing anything to change the assessed value of your property when your receive your next bill and therefore your taxes will not go up.

Next year (i.e., 2014), however, is a different story. Cochran did tell the Commentator recently that his office will be re-evaluating the manner in which properties are valued, which will have the effect of an across-the-board re-appraisal of properties. This is required by law and by the State Auditor, Cochran said. That across-the-board increase in assessments will affect your tax bill when they come out in August, 2014.

Many properties in Webster County are currently well under-valued and the new assessment will result in tax increases because of the higher across-the-board assessment. By law, if the increase in valuation is more than 10%, the Assessor must individually notify that property owner in writing of the increase so that the property owner can appeal the valuation to the County Commission. Since it is too late to increase valuations this year because the County Commission must hear the appeals in February of each year, Cochran said the new valuations will impact landowners in the next tax year (i.e., the bills that come out in August, 2014).

So, if Max Cochran is not raising your real property taxes this year, who will likely do so this year, if anyone?

Answer:  No one.  It is too late to raise property taxes this year.

The Commentator contacted Ora Ash, Director of Local Government Services with the West Virginia State Auditor's office, to inquire whether the Webster County Commission could raise its "levy rate" to raise property taxes. Property owners pay a certain amount of taxes per $100.00 of valuation of their property, which is known as the "levy rate." Ash confirmed that Webster County's levy rate is at its maximum allowable by law of 14.3 cents per $100.00 of valuation. Since Webster's levy rate is at its maximum, the County Commission can not by law raise taxes by raising the levy rate.

Ash did tell the Commentator that a County could propose an "excess levy" to raise property taxes. An "excess levy" could add up to an additional 7.15 cents per $100.00 of valuation to a landowner's tax bill if the excess levy was approved. An excess levy has to pass by 60% of the voters in the County, and Ash commented that "you don't see many new levies approved."

Since the Commission can not raise property taxes by raising the levy rate since it is already at its maximum rate, and since an excess levy would not likely be approved by the voters, the only way Webster County can raise property taxes is by raising the valuations of property, as set by the Assessor's office.  And that will not occur this year, but will impact your property taxes in 2014.

For some of our prior articles describing the budget mess, please click on this link:

http://webstercommentator.blogspot.com/2012/11/more-analysis-of-webster-countys.html
http://webstercommentator.blogspot.com/2012/11/expenses-for-county-employees-increased.html

Winter Storm Catches Webster Residents Off Guard

Above: Video shows driving to Webster Springs from Diana on Thursday morning.

A Winter storm that hit late Wednesday into Thursday morning caught most Webster County residents off guard as weather forecasters predicted a lot less snow than what actually fell. The area also saw more snow Friday afternoon compounding the accumulation totals.  Schools in Webster were closed Thursday and Friday due to the storm.

High Court Upholds Termination of Parental Rights Again

For Webster County parents involved in child abuse and neglect cases, the year 2013 is already beginning to look like a mirror image of what happened in 2012.

As previously reported by the Commentator, the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals decided 12 cases in 2012 involving parents in child abuse and neglect cases. In all but one of those 12 cases, the Supreme Court upheld the termination of the parents' rights, and almost all of the cases involved drug abuse by the parents.

It now looks like 2013 will not be any different.

On January 14, 2013, the Supreme Court upheld the termination of both a mother's and father's parental rights because of drug abuse. The case originally began after the parents gave birth to twins. These parents had two other children, who were in the custody of grandparents. The twins were born premature and were hospitalized. While they were hospitalized, the mother was found using prescription drugs illegally and was removed from the Ronald McDonald House where she was staying. The child abuse and neglect petition filed against the mother and father alleged that they had "a significant criminal and drug abuse history."

Both the mother and father made admissions to the child abuse and neglect petition and the Circuit Court based on those admissions declared them to be abusive and neglectful parents. While the case was pending, the mother tested positive for drugs and was incarcerated on a parole violation. The father was also incarcerated while the case was pending for parole violations. The Circuit Court terminated the parental rights of both the mother and father.

As to the mother, the Circuit Court found that she "had been addicted to drugs for at least the past fifteen years, that she had a significant criminal history based on her drug abuse, and that she had not participated in a drug rehabilitation program." As to the father, the Circuit Court found that "he was addicted to drugs for at least the past ten years, that he had a significant criminal history based on his drug abuse, and that he had not participated in a drug rehabilitation program."

The Supreme Court agreed with the Circuit Judge, stating that there was sufficient evidence for the Judge to find that there was "no reasonable likelihood that the conditions of abuse and neglect could be substantially corrected in the near future and that termination was necessary for the children’s welfare." The Supreme Court said that the Judge's decision was correct in light of the parents' incarceration, criminal history, and significant long term drug abuse.

For the full opinions of these new decisions discussed above, please click on the following links:

http://www.courtswv.gov/supreme-court/memo-decisions/spring2013/12-0881memo.pdf
http://www.courtswv.gov/supreme-court/memo-decisions/spring2013/12-0868memo.pdf

For a review of the 12 cases decided in 2012, please click on this link:
http://webstercommentator.blogspot.com/2012/12/webster-county-child-abuse-and-neglect.html

Trial Date Set for Triple Homicide Defendants; Bond Denied

At arraignment proceedings this morning at the Webster County Courthouse, Circuit Judge Jack Alsop set April 23, 2013 as the jury trial date for the couple charged with last year's triple homicide in Hacker Valley.

During the arraignment, Amanda York and Michael York both entered not guilty pleas to all counts of the indictments handed down against them last week by the Grand Jury.  

Both York's through their attorneys requested that the Court address the issue of bond for their clients (the York's have been held in jail without bond since their arrest on June 27, 2012). Judge Alsop declined to address the request, meaning that the York's will continue to be held without bond until trial. Amanda York is represented by Gassaway lawyer Daniel Grindo and Michael York is represented by Buckhannon lawyer Steven Nanners.

Judge Alsop also set a "discovery schedule," whereby both the State and the defendants may request  from the other side such things as discovery of evidence, list of witnesses, and similar matters prior to trial. Nanners also made a motion to hire an expert to examine his client regarding his client's alleged bi-polar condition. The Judge granted that motion. It was not made clear during the court proceedings what purpose that expert and any evaluation performed would have on the case.

Brett Morris Sets Single Game Scoring Record as Highlanders Rout 8th Ranked Rounty County

Senior Brett Morris set the all-time Highlander single game scoring record with 49 points Tuesday as  Webster routed the visiting Roane County Raiders 93 to 64.

After a grueling loss on Monday against Notre Dame which seemed to sap every bit of energy from Morris, he and the Highlanders easily bounced back in big fashion against the Raiders. Webster never trailed the entire game.

Webster jumped out to a 28 to 16 first quarter lead and never looked back. At halftime, the Highlanders led 57 to 36, with Morris leading the way with 32 points. Webster maintained a 21 point lead at the end of the third quarter at 70 to 49. With the big lead, Morris was pulled from the game until the coaches realized how close he was to the single game scoring record.

With 4:01 left in the game, Morris had a break away slam dunk to tie the record at 47 points. Then, with just 1:54 remaining in the game, Morris spun around in the lane for one of his patented easy layups to break the record with 49 points. 

(l. to r.) Hunter Given, Guy Cowger, and Brett Morris are
caught deep in thought planning their next play against
the Roane County Raiders Tuesday evening.

Former Highlander standout Tommy Williams held the previous record of 47 points in a single game. Interestingly, according to Brett's father, Williams attended Webster's pre-season scrimmage against Shady Springs and actually encouraged Brett to break his record.

A rather sparse crowd was on hand at the Highlanders' gym to witness the record breaking performance by Morris. Prior to Monday's game, the Associated Press Class AA boys' basketball poll ranked Webster 7th and Roane 8th in the State, which would lead one to believe the game Tuesday might be competitive. The Highlanders made quick work of ensuring that the result of the game was never in doubt. Webster also previously beat Roane on their home court in Spencer earlier this season.

With the win, Webster improves to 10 wins, 2 losses on the season. They now face another tough opponent on Thursday at Upperglade against the Liberty-Raleigh Raiders. Liberty-Raleigh sports a lineup featuring a 6 foot 10 inch, 305 pound center.

According to the stat sheet, Morris finished with 49 points, hitting 18 of 27 shots (66%), including 3 of 5 three point shots and 10 of 16 free throws. He also added 16 rebounds, 6 blocked shots, 3 steals, and 3 assists. Hunter Given was the only other Highlander in double figures in scoring with 14 points. Given also had 7 assists, 3 rebounds, and 1 steal.

Others playing for Webster on the stat sheet included: Dalton Davis, 6 points, 6 rebounds, 2 assists, 1 blocked shot; Lance Stout, 5 points, 3 rebounds, 1 steal, 1 assist, 1 blocked shot; Robbie Cogar, 4 points, 2 rebounds, 1 steal, 1 assist; Hunter Williams, 4 points, 3 rebounds, 1 steal; Logan Taylor, 4 points, 6 rebounds; Tyler Anderson, 3 points, 1 rebound, 1 assist; Stephen Cogar, 2 points, 2 rebounds, 1 assist, 1 steal, 1 blocked shot; Jake Thayer, 2 points, 2 assists, 1 rebound, 1 blocked shot; and Guy Cowger, 3 assists, 1 rebound. 

Irish Beat Highlanders Again

For the second time this season, the Class A Notre Dame Fighting Irish of Clarksburg handed the Class AA Webster County Highlander boy's basketball team a frustrating loss, this time by a score of 69 to 65.

Above: Brett Morris has controlled the opening tip off in all 11 of Webster's
games this season.

Unlike the game earlier this season which the Irish won by 26 points, the host Highlanders gave the near capacity home crowd Monday evening a lot to cheer about as they led 20 to 15 at the end of the first quarter. Webster added to that lead and built up an 11 point advantage at halftime at 31 to 20, only to see that lead evaporate in the third quarter, which ended tied at 48.

Well after the game, senior Tyler Anderson best summed up the game and what then transpired during the fourth quarter: "We were tired, they were fresh." The Highlanders had every opportunity in the fourth quarter to win the game, but an obviously tired Webster team came up short. The Irish played much better than their now 4 win, 6 loss record would indicate.

Senior Brett Morris appeared to carry the Highlanders on his back for most of the game. He finished with a season single game high of 34 points. He also had 12 rebounds, 7 blocked shots, 4 assists, and 3 steals. Morris cramped up badly right before halftime and it appeared that strain took its toll on him during the second half as he looked to be on the verge of exhaustion but never gave up.

Senior Hunter Given was the only other Webster player scoring double figures, with 11 points. Given added 11 rebounds and 6 assists. Others playing for Webster on the stat sheet included: Logan Taylor, 7 points, 1 rebound; Dalton Davis, 7 points, 2 rebounds, 2 steals, 1 assist, 1 blocked shot; Robbie Cogar, 6 points, 3 rebounds, 1 assist, 1 steal; Guy Cowger, 1 rebound, 1 steal, 1 assist; and Hunter Williams, 2 rebounds.

With the loss, the Highlanders drop to 9 wins, 2 losses on the season. They have little time to recuperate as they entertain the 11 win, 2 loss Roane County Raiders on Tuesday, January 22, 2013.

On a bright note, in the early game, the Lady Highlanders came from behind to beat the Lady Irish in a barn burner. The Lady Highlanders have twice beaten the Lady Irish, and improved their record to 9 wins, 5 losses on the season.

Tough Week Ahead for Highlander Basketball Teams

The Webster County Highlander boys' basketball team will face three tough teams this upcoming week.

Last Thursday's game against Liberty-Raleigh that was cancelled due to weather has been rescheduled for Thursday, January 24, 2013. In addition, the Highlanders play Notre Dame on Monday, January 21, 2013, and Roane County on Tuesday, January 22, 2013. All three games are home games for Webster.

Although they have only a 3 win, 6 loss record, Notre Dame is the only team to prevail over the Highlanders this season. Roane County currently sports an 11 win, 2 loss record, and Liberty-Raleigh is ranked within the top 10 in Class AA.

Monday's game against Notre Dame is scheduled as a girls/boys double-header, with the girls playing at 5:45 p.m. and the boys at 7:30 p.m. The girls also play on Wednesday against Greenbrier West and on Friday against Braxton County, both games at Upperglade.

Unemployment Continues to Climb in Webster County

The unemployment rate in Webster County climbed yet again, now standing at a whopping 13.7 percent for December, 2012.

According to data from WorkForceWV.org, unemployment increased in 53 of West Virginia's 55 counties. Only Brooke and Pocahontas counties saw decreases. The statewide average climbed to 7.5 percent for December, 2012.

Webster County maintained its hold on being the county with the second highest unemployment in the State. Likewise, neighboring Clay County kept its number one distinction, with unemployment in Clay at 14.9 percent for December, 2012.

Only three counties, Putnam, Jefferson, and Monongalia, had unemployment rates below 6 percent. Joining Clay and Webster with unemployment rates above 11 percent were Calhoun, Roane, Wetzel, Wyoming, and Grant counties. 

Most interesting of the counties on the list with unemployment in excess of 11 percent is Wetzel County (at 11.5 percent). Wetzel County has been the focus of intense Marcellus Shale gas drilling in the past few years. Because most of those drilling jobs were occupied by out of state workers and were short term in nature at that, the alleged job boon from this type of gas drilling has had little effect if any on the local job market in Wetzel County. This should be "food for thought" when the gas drilling industry comes knocking on Webster County's doors with shallow promises of job creation.

For further details about the unemployment rates, please click on this link:

http://www.workforcewv.org/lmi/datarel/cnty_PR.pdf

Brett Morris Breaks Yet Another Record as Webster Wins First Ever Game With PikeView

This might sound like a broken record, but Brett Morris did it again; that is, broke yet another record.

In the Highlanders' 68 to 54 win over the visiting PikeView Panthers Saturday evening, Morris became the all-time leading basketball scorer in the history of Webster County. Previously, Morris broke the all-time Webster County Highlander scoring record. Now he is the all-time leading scorer of all schools in Webster County history. The previous all school record was held by Jamie Tanner, a lady basketball player, who amassed 1,330 points during her career at Webster Springs Elementary School and the Webster County High School.

Morris broke the record in grand fashion. With just 22 seconds remaining in the game, senior Hunter Williams had an opportunity to score an easy layup, but instead threw Morris a "lob" pass, which Morris then slammed home to the delight of the home crowd. That was Morris' second slam dunk of the game. In a brief post-game interview, Morris was asked in light of all his accomplishments what was left to achieve. "A state championship," he said. 

Guy Cowger (left) and Brett Morris, both happy with their
win over Pikeview and Brett's record setting performance.

Despite the final score, the Highlanders played sluggish in the first half, leading at the end of the first quarter 16 to 13, and by 30 to 25 at halftime. Fortunately, senior Guy Cowger provided a spark by  scoring 4 of his 8 points and grabbing 3 of his 6 rebounds in the first half. After the game, of all the teams Webster has faced this year, Cowger said PikeView "was one of the better teams, but not good enough for us" tonight. 

Webster came out strong in the third quarter, outscoring the Panthers 21 to 12, to take a 51 to 37 lead to begin the final quarter. Of everything Morris did during the PikeView game, it was two key assists in the fourth quarter that were perhaps his best plays of the game. After PikeView cut Webster's lead down to 8 with 3:19 remaining in the game, Morris threw a no look pass to freshman Robbie Cogar who scored a quick basket to extend the lead back to 10 with 3:02 remaining. Then, just 20 seconds later, Morris threw another no look pass to senior Hunter Given for another easy score, and Webster led by 12, squelching any comeback hopes of PikeView. This was the first time the two schools have played each other.

Morris led the Highlanders with 20 points, 13 rebounds, 9 blocked shots, 4 assists, and 2 steals. Hunter Given had 17 points, 8 rebounds, 2 assists, 2 steals, and 1 blocked shot. Cowger had 8 points, 6 rebounds, and 3 assists.

Others playing for Webster on the stat sheet included: Dalton Davis, 6 points, 4 rebounds, 2 blocked shots; Hunter Williams, 5 points, 1 assist; Logan Taylor, 5 points, 1 rebound; Stephen Cogar, 4 points, 3 assists, 2 rebounds; Robbie Cogar, 3 points, 2 rebounds, 1 assist, 1 steal.

As a team, Webster made 51% of their shots, but only 38% of their free throws.

With the win, Webster improved to 9 wins, 1 loss on the season. They next face the Notre Dame Fighting Irish (the only team to beat them this year) on Monday, January 21, 2013 at Upperglade, followed on Tuesday, January 22, 2013, with a rematch against the Roane County Raiders, also at Upperglade.

'Life Sentence' for Family, Friends of Triple Homicide Victims

Above: Denise Coates, Bobbie Brown (wife
of Dustin), Dustin Brown, and Lamar Coates on
Bobbie and Dustin's wedding day.

As the legal system slowly churns its way in seeking justice for the victims of last year's triple homicide, and as attention is paid to the alleged perpetrators with the recent Grand Jury indictments, the Commentator pauses to remember the victims of this tragedy.

Dustin Tyler Brown, Denise L. Coates, and Lamar D. "LA" Coates lost their lives on June 27, 2012. As Dustin's mother, Reta Lake Brown, stated in an email to the Commentator regarding the picture below of the bench by Dustin's grave, that "is the end result of our lifetime sentence." More photos of Dustin can be viewed on his memorial Facebook page:

https://www.facebook.com/InMemoryOfDustinTylerBrown

Above: Dustin Tyler Brown (right), with brother Adam, and sisters Courtney, Madison, Cheyenne, and Jordan.

Above: The memorial bench at Dustin's grave site.

Drug, Child Neglect, Firearm, & Theft Crimes Occupy Balance of Grand Jury Proceedings

In addition to the murder indictments handed down against Michael York and Amanda York on January 16, 2013, the Webster County Grand Jury also returned indictments against several people involved in drug, child neglect, firearm, and theft related crimes.

RONALD JAMES WARD and KIMBERLY SUE HINKLE

Ronald James Ward

Ronald James Ward and Kimberly Sue Hinkle were charged in a joint indictment. Both Ward and Hinkle were each indicted on the felony crimes of Operating or Attempting to Operate a Clandestine Drug Laboratory, Conspiracy to operate such clandestine drug lab, and Possession of Substances Used as a Precursor to the Manufacture of Methamphetamine. Their indictment alleges that on September 24, 2012, Ward and Hinkle conspired together to operate a clandestine drug lab, and that one or both of them did an act to effect the object of the conspiracy by obtaining equipment and/or chemicals and/or materials for use in a clandestine drug lab.

Their indictment further alleges that on September 24, 2012, Ward and Hinkle operated or attempted to operate a methamphetamine ("meth") drug lab, by assembling coffee filters and/or lye and/or Kingston Lighter Fluid and/or tubing and/or pseudo ephedrine to manufacture meth. Their indictment also alleges they knowingly possessed pseudo ephedrine or its salts, optical isomers or salts of optical isomers in a state or form which is, or has been altered or converted from the state or form in which these chemicals are, or were, commercially distributed by possessing pseudo ephedrine which had been crushed and/or altered into chunks and/or powder form. The indictments against Ward and Hinkle were found by the Grand Jury upon the testimony of State Police Trooper E.E. Bostic.

Brian E. Hall

BRIAN EUGENE HALL

Brian E. Hall was indicted on five felonies. He is charged with Delivery of a Controlled Substance, for allegedly delivering morphine, a narcotic substance, to a confidential informant for the Central West Virginia Drug Task Force on January 10, 2012. He is also charged with Conspiracy to Deliver a Controlled Substance, by allegedly conspiring with Rodney P. Johnson on January 10, 2012 to deliver a controlled substance, and that one of them did an act in furtherance of the conspiracy, in that Brian Hall did arrange the delivery via telephone and/or Rodney P. Johnson did deliver a controlled substance to another person.

Hall was also indicted for three counts of Child Neglect Creating a Substantial Risk of Serious Bodily Injury or Death, by allegedly selling drugs in the presence of three different minor children on January 10, 2012. The indictment against Hall was found upon the testimony of Sergeant Paul Kutcher.

LESTER T. BARNHOUSE and LISA A. DAVIS

Lester Barnhouse

The Grand Jury returned a joint indictment against Lester T. Barnhouse and Lisa A. Davis, charging them each with the felony crimes of Operating a Clandestine Drug Lab and Conspiracy to operate a clandestine drug lab. Their indictment alleges that on November 1, 2011, Barnhouse and Davis operated or attempted to operate a meth lab by gathering pseudo ephedrine and/or various chemicals and/or various equipment, and having the same on property belonging to Johnny Fox and/or Junior Fox, for the purpose of manufacturing meth. The indictment further alleges that on November 1, 2012, they conspired with each other and/or Johnny Fox to operate or attempt to operate the meth lab and that one of them did an act in furtherance of their conspiracy, by one of them gathering pseudo ephedrine and/or various chemicals and/or various equipment for the purpose of operating a meth lab. This indictment was found upon the testimony of State Police Trooper E.E. Bostic.

JUSTIN P. McKENZIE

The Grand Jury returned a two count felony indictment against Justin P. McKenzie. McKenzie was indicted for Delivery of a Controlled Substance for allegedly delivering morphine, a narcotic substance, to a cooperating individual working with the Central West Virginia Drug Task Force on September 19, 2011. McKenzie was also indicted for Delivery of a Controlled Substance for allegedly delivering morphine to a cooperating individual working with the Central West Virginia Drug Task Force on September 20, 2011. This indictment was found upon the testimony of Sergeant Paul Kutcher and others unnamed.

SCOTTIE L. THOMAS

An indictment for five felonies and one misdemeanor was issued against Scottie L. Thomas. Thomas was indicted for two counts of Possession with Intent to Deliver a Controlled Substance, for allegedly possessing with the intent to deliver both meth and morphine on February 1, 2012. He was also indicted for Conspiracy to Possess with Intent to Deliver a Controlled Substance by conspiring with Ralph Vannoy and/or Gabrielle Fleming to possess meth and/or morphine, and one or more of such persons did an act in furtherance of the conspiracy by possessing meth or morphine with the intent to deliver the same. Also on Feburary 1, 2012, Thomas was indicted for Operating or Attempting to Operate a Clandestine Drug Laboratory by using property to assemble coffee filters and/or lithium batteries and/or Clariton-D and/or pseudo ephedrine and/or various equipment and chemicals for the purpose of making meth. He was also indicted for Conspiracy to Operate or Attempt to Operate a meth lab by conspiring with Ralph Vannoy and/or Gabrielle Fleming and that one or more of them did an act in furtherance of the conspiracy by obtaining equipment and/or chemicals and/or materials for a clandestine drug lab and/or for operating a clandestine drug lab.  The Grand Jury also issued a misdemeanor charge against Thomas for Carrying a Concealed Weapon Without a State License or Other Authorization for allegedly carrying a concealed deadly weapon on February 1, 2012, being a Bryce Arms 9mm pistol. This indictment was found upon the testimony of State Police Trooper S.C. Baier.

KENNETH L. BUTCHER

Kenneth L. Butcher

A four count felony indictment was issued against Kenneth L. Butcher. The indictment charges Butcher with Daytime Burglary, alleging that on August 15, 2012, Butcher entered without breaking, in the daytime, the dwelling house of Michael Carpenter and/or Joyce H. Morton located at 1792 Webster Road, by entering through an unlocked door with the intent to commit a crime therein, being larceny. Related to this charge is the offense of Grand Larceny issued against Butcher for stealing from Carpenter and/or Morton property valued at more than $1,000.00, being four different firearms, $70.00 in cash, and a 14K gold diamond cluster ring.

The indictment also charges Butcher with two counts of Conspiracy, for allegedly conspiring with Alex Cogar to commit Daytime Burglary and Grand Larceny, and that one or more of such persons did an act in furtherance of the conspiracies by entering the home of Carpenter and/or Morton and by stealing the property listed above. This indictment was found upon the testimony of State Police Trooper S.G. Blake.

PHYLLIS ANNE STARCHER

Phyllis Anne Starcher was indicted for three felony crimes and one misdemeanor, including three felony counts of Possession with Intent to Deliver a Controlled Substance, by allegedly possessing on May 15, 2012 hydrocodone, alprazolam, and buprenorphine, with the intent to deliver said substances. A fourth count charges the misdemeanor crime of Delivery of a Controlled Substance, alleging that Starcher delivered buprenorphine to an individual cooperating with the West Virginia State Police. The Grand Jury found this indictment based upon the testimony of State Police Trooper E.E. Bostic.

WESLEY WAYNE

A six felony count indictment was issued against Wesley Wayne for actions that allegedly occurred on July 3, 2012. Wayne is charged with four counts of Wanton Endangerment Involving a Firearm, and two counts of Child Neglect Creating Substantial Risk of Serious Bodily Injury or Death. All six counts in this indictment allege that Wayne pointed an AR-15 type, Model ST-15, .223 semi-automatic rifle at Katina Wayne, Stacy Williams, and two minors, and/or firing said rifle in the direction of Katina Wayne, Stacy Williams, and the two minors. This indictment was found upon the testimony of Webster County Deputy Sheriff Rick Clayton.

DAVID D. MYERS

The Grand Jury charged David D. Myers with seven felony crimes. The indictment charges three counts of Operating or Attempting to Operate a Clandestine Drug Laboratory, all on May 19, 2011, at three different locations, being on the tailgate of a certain Chevy pickup truck, on a toolbox in a certain garage floor, and in a certain clear plastic bottle with a red lid. The indictment further charges two counts of Possession of Substances to be Used as a Precursor to Manufacture Methamphetamine, in that on May 19, 2011, Myers allegedly possessed about 40 unopened pseudo ephedrine pills with the intent to use them in making meth, and allegedly possessed pseudo ephedrine dissolved in a liquid. The indictment also charges Myers with one count of Conspiracy, for allegedly conspiring on May 19, 2011 with Howard Lane and/or Pamela J. Carpenter to operate a meth lab and that one or more of such persons did an act in furtherance of the conspiracy by obtaining equipment and/or chemicals and/or materials for a drug lab, and/or by operating a drug lab. This indictment was found upon the testimony of Deputy Rick Clayton.

The foreperson of the Grand Jury signing each of the above indictments was Clark R. White. Indictments are merely formal charges or accusations and are not evidence of guilt. A Grand Jury hears only the evidence presented by the Prosecuting Attorney in deciding whether to charge any individual with a crime. Arraignments on these indictments are scheduled for January 23, 2012 before Circuit Judge Jack Alsop.

Grand Jury Indicts Couple in Triple Homicide

Michael York

Among the many indictments returned by the Webster County Grand Jury which met on January 16, 2013 was the joint indictment against Michael York and Amanda York for the triple homicide that occurred in Hacker Valley on June 27, 2012.

Michael York was indicted for three counts of the felony crime of Murder, for the murders of Lamar D. Allen, also known as Elle (L.A.) Coates, Denise L. Coates, and Dustin T. Brown, by the use, presentment, or brandishing of a firearm. Michael York was also indicted for the felony crime of Concealment of a Deceased Human Body, being the body of Dustin T. Brown, by moving and attempting to conceal said body, where death occurred as a result of criminal activity, being the shooting of Dustin T. Brown.

Michael York was also indicted for the felony crime of Prohibited Person Possessing a Firearm, in that he was previously convicted of a felony crime of violence against the person of another, being Felonious Assault, in Lorain County, Ohio, on or about April 15, 2008, and did thereafter possess a firearm, being a Remington Model 700 .30-06 rifle, and/or a JC Higgins/Sears bolt action shotgun, and/or a JC Higgins/Sears Model 20 .12 gauge shotgun, and/or a Springfield Model L7F .20 gauge shotgun.

Michael York was further indicted on two felony Conspiracy charges, being a charge of conspiracy with Amanda York to conceal the deceased body of Dustin T. Brown, and a charge of conspiracy with Amanda York to murder the three above-name victims.

In all, Michael York was indicted on seven felony crimes. Amanda York was indicted on five similar felony crimes.

Amanda York

Amanda York was indicted for the same three felony murder charges brought against Michael York and on the same two conspiracy charges also brought against Michael York, as more fully detailed above.

Both York's remain incarcerated and are being held without bond. Indictments are merely formal charges or accusations and are not evidence of guilt. A Grand Jury hears only the evidence presented by the Prosecuting Attorney in deciding whether to charge any individual with a crime.

The Grand Jury foreperson signing the York's indictments was Clark R. White. The indictments against the York's were founded upon the testimony of State Police Trooper S.C. Baier.

UPDATE: The York's and the other people indicted will be arraigned in front of Circuit Judge Jack Alsop on Wednesday, January 23, 2013, beginning at 9:00 a.m. in the Circuit Courtroom of the Webster County Courthouse in Webster Springs, West Virginia. An arraignment is a hearing to determine whether an indicted person desires to enter a plea of guilty or not guilty, or defer the plea until a later date, and to set trial dates. Unlike the Grand Jury proceedings which are secret, the arraignment is an open hearing at which the public may attend.

The Commentator will post another article soon on the rest of the indictments returned by the Grand Jury on January 16, 2013.

Lights Are On But Nobody Is Home at Family Dollar

As the saying goes, "the lights are on, but nobody is home" at the new Family Dollar Store in Webster Springs. Despite earlier reports that the new store would be open for business in January, 2013, the store remains totally vacant.

Electrical contractors continue to work inside the store, and each day passers by can see all the lights on in and outside of the store. No inventory has been moved into the store as of yet. The older Family Dollar store next to the G&R IGA continues to remain open.

Calls to corporate headquarters have not yet been returned as to when the move from the old store to the new store will occur.

Highlanders' Defensive Pressure Sinks Braxton County

A second half full court press by the Highlanders helped Webster to break open a tight game at halftime and Webster ran away with the win 72 to 43 over the host Braxton County Eagles at the Braxton Armory Tuesday evening.

The pesky Eagles held a surprising 14 to 13 lead at the end of the first quarter after Webster had jumped out to an early 6 to 0 lead. Webster edged Braxton 12 to 9 in the second quarter, and the Highlanders went into halftime with a precarious 25 to 23 lead.

According to junior guard Stephen Cogar, head coach Jerry Dean at halftime "lined us out on a couple plays and we started running them better" and "our press really helped us." That might be the understatement of the game as Webster's press in the third quarter caused countless Eagle turnovers and the Highlanders outscored Braxton 32 to 6 to lead at the end of the quarter 57 to 29. The Highlanders then coasted during the fourth quarter to the final margin of victory at 72 to 43.

Cogar was one of four Highlanders scoring in double figures. He finished with 12 points, 3 rebounds, 3 steals, and 2 assists. Joining Cogar in double figures were: Brett Morris, 19 points, 12 rebounds, 9 assists, 4 blocked shots; Hunter Given, 11 points, 6 rebounds, 3 steals, 2 assists; and Dalton Davis, 10 points, 6 rebounds, 1 steal.

Others playing for Webster on the stat sheet provided by Diane Morris included: Tyler Anderson, 7 points, 1 rebound; Jake Thayer, 4 points, 1 rebound; Lance Stout, 3 points, 2 assists, 1 steal; David Muzny, 3 points, 2 rebounds, 1 steal, 1 assist; Logan Taylor, 3 points, 4 rebounds; Guy Cowger, 3 steals, 3 assists; Robbie Cogar, 1 steal; and Rick Holcomb, 3 rebounds.

As a team, Webster made 22 of 53 shot attempts (43%), which was a marked improvement from halftime prior to which they had made only 30% of their shots. Webster also made 21 of 31 free throw attempts (67%).

With the win, the Highlanders improved to 8 wins, 1 loss on the season. They now face perhaps their toughest opponent of the season thus far when they host the Liberty-Raleigh Raiders this Thursday, January 17, 2013, at the Highlanders' gym. All fans are encouraged to wear white for a "white out" of the Raiders.

Webster Couple Charged with Multiple Crimes Related to Car Chase near Camden on Gauley

Above: Travis Mack Hammons, age 22, was charged on Sunday with two felonies and four misdemeanors. He is being held at the Central Regional Jail on a $90,000.00 bond ($25,000.00 on each felony; $10,000.00 on each misdemeanor).

Above: Ellisha Dawn Hammons, age 18, was charged on Sunday with one felony and three misdemeanors and is being held at the Central Regional Jail on a $55,000.00 bond ($25,000.00 on the felony; $10,000.00 on each misdemeanor).

The West Virginia State Police have charged a Webster couple with multiple felony and misdemeanor offenses after a car chase near Camden on Gauley this past Sunday.

State Police pulled over a vehicle allegedly being driven erratically by Travis Mack Hammons, age 22. Also in the vehicle was his wife, Ellisha Dawn Hammons, age 18. After the vehicle was stopped, the couple then allegedly fled the scene of the stop, later bailed out on foot, fled on foot, and were eventually captured by two State Police officers.

Travis Hammons was charged with the felony offense of Fleeing While DUI and the felony offense of Conspiracy for allegedly conspiring with his wife, Ellisha, who allegedly told Travis to run over one of the officers when they sped away. Travis was also charged with the misdemeanor offenses of DUI, Fleeing on Foot, and two counts of Obstructing an Officer. Ellisha was charged with a similar felony offense of Conspiracy. She was also charged with the misdemeanor offenses of Fleeing on Foot, and two counts of Obstructing an Officer.

Both Hammons' were arraigned by Magistrate John Stone, who set a cash bond of $90,000.00 for Travis and $55,000.00 for Ellisha. Both remain incarcerated at the Central Regional Jail. These are charges only, and are not an indication of the guilt of these parties.

Highlanders Remain 6th in AP Poll; 16th in MaxPreps Poll

The Webster County Highlander boys' basketball team remain ranked sixth in Class AA according to the poll released by the Associated Press today. Last week, the Highlanders were tied for sixth with Roane County.  

Here are the top 10 Class AA teams ranked by the Associated Press writers, and each team's respective win-loss record:

1. Bluefield, 7-1  
2. Poca, 9-1   
3. Scott, 8-2
4. Wyoming East, 7-2
5. Robert C. Byrd, 8-2
6. Webster County, 7-1
7. Tolsia, 6-5 
8. Fairmont Senior, 7-3
9. Roane County, 10-2
10. Westside, 6-4    

Others receiving votes in the AP poll: Liberty Raleigh, Bridgeport, North Marion, Chapmanville, Summers County, Ritchie County, Nicholas County. Webster has played or will play only two teams currently on this list (Roane County and Liberty Raleigh).

According to the MaxPreps.com poll, Webster remains at 16th. Here are the top 16 Class AA teams ranked by MaxPreps:

1 Bluefield, 7-1
2 Poca, 10-1
3 Robert C. Byrd, 8-2
4 Wyoming East, 7-2
5 Scott, 8-2
6 Fairmont, 7-3
7 Summers County, 6-4
8 Bridgeport, 5-4
9 Tolsia, 6-5
10 Liberty Raleigh, 6-2
11 Mingo Central, 5-4
12 Nicholas County, 6-3
13 Chapmanville Regional, 6-4
14 Herbert Hoover, 6-3
15 WestSide, 6-5
16 Webster County, 7-1

Through their first 8 games of the season, the Highlanders are averaging 71.875 points per game on offense, and have held their opponents to an average of 56.125 points per game, for an average margin of victory of about 15.5 points per game. Not surprisingly, senior Brett Morris leads the Highlanders in scoring, averaging 22.5 points per game.

Bergoo Raw Sewage Issue Nothing New But Getting Worse

About 50 households in Bergoo have a private sewer system over 80 years old which dumps raw sewage directly into Leatherwood Creek and the Elk River.

This sign could easily appear in Bergoo, to notify 

 folks downstream of the raw sewage being

dumped into the Elk River.

For the past two decades, residents on this private system have requested state and local officials to put them on a public sewage system. Now, their private aging system is breaking down causing pipes to clog and contaminating at least one household's drinking well. All of these residents have private water supplies that are in danger of contamination due to the leaks in the system.

When Webster County Health Department Sanitarian George Clutter was quoted in an interview yesterday on WDTV of Clarksburg that folks in the State Capitol in Charleston are making their coffee with raw sewage from Bergoo, he was not kidding, as Charleston draws their water supply fed in part by the Elk River. Likewise, when folks downriver of Bergoo (which take their water supply from Elk) drink their water, they likewise are taking a sip of the Bergoo raw sewage (of course, the water is treated and filtered before it reaches their taps).

The private Bergoo system is nothing more than a series of pipes without any type of filtration that dumps raw sewage into either Leatherwood Creek or further down at the Elk River. Because it is a private system, just like any private septic system, the County does not and can not by law maintain the system. If it breaks, it is the responsibility of the users to fix and/or maintain it.

When environmental laws were passed in West Virginia prohibiting the dumping of raw sewage into creeks and rivers, existing systems, like the old Bergoo system, were "grandfathered" into the law, which basically meant that were exempt from the law. The big rub here, rather the big smell, is that this is the year 2012 and no one should be allowed to dump raw sewage into our streams and rivers, particularly when those waters are used as water supplies for towns and cities.

Contacted Saturday before the "hoopla" created by WDTV's appearance, Bergoo resident Libby Hamrick told the Commentator that the system is breaking down. She noted that Chuck and Cathy Bonnett are the first residents to have the most serious problem from the failing system, as their water well is now contaminated with raw sewage. According to Hamrick, and as confirmed by the Bonnett's to WDTV, tests have confirmed the contamination.

Hamrick said that many times her husband Jeff has spread lime along Leatherwood Creek in the Summer when the smell of the raw sewage gets bad during low water periods. She said he has also had to clean out the place where the sewage enters the Creek, as well as enlisting the help of the local fire department to flush their lines, and neighbors' lines.

Putting these Bergoo residents on a public sewage system is not only long overdue, it is the only solution. Lot sizes for almost all residents are too small to put in individual private septic systems.

Toilet paper from the Bergoo raw sewage pipes are often
found clinging along trees on the banks of the Elk River.

Hamrick feels that public officials have overlooked this problem for years because the system is a private system, not subject to public oversight. "It's not their responsibility so they don't help us," she said.

The Commentator also contacted County Commissioner Chuck Armentrout to get his response to the complaints being raised by the Bergoo residents. "We have been actively working on this problem for years. We have applied for funding for a public project for Bergoo, but this is a cost per customer issue. We can't compete with larger city projects where more customers would be served by the same amount of grant money," Armentrout noted.

Even though the Bergoo project has been turned down in the past, Armentrout said there is a ray of hope on the horizon. "We are sixth on the priority list for funding of a project like this," he noted. The Commissioner said that the County Commission has taken action in the past by securing a $25,000.00 grant to the Public Service District so that preliminary studies and audits could be completed.  Those audits and studies were necessary to qualify the Bergoo project for the funding, and it appears the money was well spent since it landed the Bergoo project sixth among over a hundred similar type projects across the State of West Virginia.

Armentrout hopes that by this Spring or Summer, a final decision will be reached on whether the project will be funded. If it is, Armentrout said the project could be completed within a year.

As to what the project entails, Armentrout said it would be similar to a very large, over-sized septic system. "There would be very little maintenance on this system, and it would be electronically monitored by the Public Service District," he added. Every five to seven years, the sludge water in the system would have to be pumped out and taken to a waste water treatment plant, for eventual filtration, treatment, and discharge back into the river like that occurring at the plant below Dorrtown along the Elk.