Sunday, December 30, 2012

Top Ten Commentator Articles for 2012

The Commentator first began on October 19, 2012. As the year closes, we have published 115 articles, with now over 22,650 page views. Here are the top ten articles in terms of views by our readers (with direct links to those articles following the headline):

10. BREAKING NEWS: Superintendent Proposes Closing Diana Grade School
http://webstercommentator.blogspot.com/2012/10/breaking-news-superintendent-proposes.html

9. WV State Police Sex Offender Registry for Webster County
http://webstercommentator.blogspot.com/2012/11/wv-state-police-sex-offender-registry.html

8. Hit & Run Driver Damages Visitors Center
http://webstercommentator.blogspot.com/2012/12/hit-run-driver-damages-visitors-center.html

7. School Consolidation Plan Hot Topic at Recent Board at Recent Board of Education Meeting
http://webstercommentator.blogspot.com/2012/11/school-consolidation-plan-hot-topic-at.html

6. Holly River State Park: Outdoor Lovers' Delight
http://webstercommentator.blogspot.com/2012/12/holly-river-state-park-outdoor-lovers.html

5. Interim Sheriff Appointed for Webster County
http://webstercommentator.blogspot.com/2012/10/interim-sheriff-appointed-for-webster.html

4. Strong Opposition to School Consolidation Plan Voiced at Diana Public Meeting
http://webstercommentator.blogspot.com/2012/12/strong-opposition-to-school.html

3. Erbacon Arson Update: Man Charged with 5 Felonies
http://webstercommentator.blogspot.com/2012/12/erbacon-arson-update-man-charged-with-5.html

2. BREAKING NEWS: Murder Conviction for Julia Surbaugh Set Aside by WV Supreme Court; New Trial to be Scheduled
http://webstercommentator.blogspot.com/2012/11/murder-conviction-for-julia-surbaugh.html

1. BREAKING NEWS: Superintendent Withdraws School Consolidation Plan
http://webstercommentator.blogspot.com/2012/12/breaking-news-superintendent-withdraws.html

Saturday, December 29, 2012

Stat Lady Diane Morris: Thank You

As a lot of fans already know, Diane Morris uses her I-Pad to compile a large variety of statistics during the Webster County Highlander boys' varsity basketball games. Every time the Commentator has compared her statistics to the official scorer statistics she is dead on right. In addition, she compiles statistics that even the official scorer does not compile. We are indebted to Diane for the job she does every game. Below are how the statistics look from each game. These statistics include a shot chart, individual player statistics, and the play by play statistics.
Shown above are the individual player statistics for the Highlanders from the December 28, 2012 Notre Dame game.
Shown above is part of the first quarter of the play by play statistics from the December 28,
2012 game against Notre Dame. We show this first part for space reasons only.

Shown above is the shooting chart from the Highlanders' game against Grafton on December 27, 2012. The green circles show shots made and the location of the shot with the player number in the circle; the red circles show missed shots.

Friday, December 28, 2012

Highlanders Suffer First Loss of Season


There is one priceless moment in the above highlight video: After Tyler Anderson drills a long 3 point shot, watch the reaction (or disbelief) of Notre Dame coach Jarrod West (at about 1:20 into the video).

Host school Notre Dame did not need the "luck of the Irish" Friday evening in Clarksburg as they demolished the Webster County Highlander boy's basketball team by a score of 81 to 55 to win the BB&T Holiday Tournament.

The Fighting Irish of Notre Dame led at the end of each quarter, building their lead as the game progressed. The Irish led 17 to 14 at the end of the 1st quarter, 35 to 25 at halftime, 56 to 41 at the end of the third quarter, and outscored Webster 25 to 14 in the fourth quarter.

If there was at least one bright spot for Webster County, it was the aggressive play on both defense and offense by junior center Dalton Davis when he was in the game. Davis scored 15 points and had a team high 12 rebounds, and also had 1 steal. Davis was often found contesting Notre Dame shots under the hoop and contending for offensive rebounds when Webster had the ball. Davis made a hot 77% of his shots. In this reporter's opinion, Davis has the ability to play this well every game if he stays aggressive and asserts himself as he did Friday evening.

Sadly, the game was marred throughout by the perception of Highlander fans that the referees were "one-sided" for Notre Dame. One female Webster fan was even ejected from the game during the latter part of the third quarter for constantly yelling at one referee in particular.

Perception of the referees is one thing but actual video of the game is another. As most readers know, this reporter films most of the Highlander boys games. A review of the video of most of the hotly contested calls made against Webster actually show that the referees got it right. Granted, the referees could have called fouls against the Notre Dame players more often, but the fouls called on the Webster players were, for the most part, correct. That may be a tough pill to swallow for some folks, but the video supports that conclusion. This conclusion is further supported by the game statistics: The referees called 26 fouls on Notre Dame and only 20 on Webster, which included 1 technical foul.

This reporter sat directly behind Notre Dame head coach Jarrod West. West played basketball at WVU where he was a three-time Academic All-American and co-captain of the team. In 1998, he was a member of the WVU team that participated in the NCAA tournament. During Friday's game, West constantly implored his Irish players to expose the weaknesses in the Highlanders. His game plan as overheard by many was well thought out and his players executed it perfectly throughout the game. 

No amount of "bad refereeing" can be used as the excuse for how well the Irish played. Friday evening, Notre Dame was just the better team on the Court. Fortunately for Webster, they have the ability to easily regroup from this loss and move on to better results. Had this been a close game, this reporter would also question the loss due to the calls made by the referees. Time to move on.

Hunter Given led all Webster scorers with 17 points, and he added 7 rebounds, 3 blocked shots, and 2 steals. Brett Morris scored 14 points and had 7 rebounds, 5 blocked shots, 3 assists, and 1 steal. Others playing for Webster included: Tyler Anderson, 3 points; Guy Cowger, 3 points, 3 rebounds, 2 steals, and 2 assists; Stephen Cogar, 2 points, 3 rebounds; Rick Holcomb, 1 point; Logan Taylor, 3 rebounds, 1 assist; and Lance Stout, 1 rebound. As a team, Webster made 20 of 51 shots for a 39% shooting percentage, and made only 12 of 28 free throws, or 42%.

Webster's record drops to four wins, one loss on the season and they next play at Midland Trail on Thursday, January 3, 2013.

On a bright note for Webster County, the Lady Highlanders won the girls Holiday Tournament, beating the host Irish by a score of 46 to 40.

Highlanders Advance to Championship Game of Holiday Tournament



Webster County's dynamic duo of seniors Brett Morris and Hunter Given combined for 49 points to lead the Highlanders to a 67 to 60 win over the Grafton Bearcats in an opening round game of the BB&T Holiday Tournament in Clarksburg Thursday evening.

Morris led his team in scoring with 29 points, despite sitting out most of the third quarter after he was incorrectly attributed his fourth foul of the game. The official scorer from Grafton listed Morris with 4 fouls when in reality Morris was attributed a foul actually made by teammate Given. While Morris sat on the bench in the third quarter, Given took over with basket after basket ending the game with 20 points.

Grafton owned the first quarter, holding a 6 point lead with just seconds remaining when Morris poured in a 3 point shot as the buzzer expired, and Grafton led 14 to 11. In the second quarter, Grafton raced out to an early 22 to 11 lead before the Highlanders climbed back to pull within 2 to trail at halftime 32 to 30. That 11 point deficit was the largest deficit the Highlanders have faced in their four games this season.

Before Morris got into foul trouble in the third quarter, senior Lance Stout made a short pass to a leaping Morris for a slam dunk which sparked the Highlander offense. After Morris was benched for foul trouble, Given then scored 11 of his 20 points in the third quarter. Webster led 49 to 46 at the end of the third quarter. 

It appeared that the Highlanders might run away with the game when they opened up an 8 point lead at 58 to 50, but the Bearcats clawed back to within 2 at 58 to 56 with 5:18 remaining in the game. The teams traded baskets for the next three minutes and Webster clung to a 2 point lead at 62 to 60 with 1:58 remaining. 

With less than a minute remaining, and after Given made one of two foul shots giving Webster a 63 to 60 lead, Grafton blew two chances to tie the game at 63. Morris then tipped in an errant shot by junior Logan Taylor for a 65 to 60 Webster lead with 14 seconds remaining. Morris added a couple foul shots for the final 67 to 60 margin of victory.

Team statistics: Morris, 29 points, 8 rebounds, 3 steals, 3 blocked shots, 1 assist; Given, 20 points, 7 rebounds, 2 assists, 1 blocked shot, 1 steal; Lance Stout, 6 points, 3 assists, 1 steal; Hunter Williams, 5 points, 1 rebound; Tyler Anderson, 3 points, 1 rebound; Dalton Davis, 2 points, 4 rebounds, 1 steal; Stephen Cogar, 2 points, 7 rebounds, 2 steals; Guy Cowger, 2 rebounds, 1 steal; Logan Taylor, 3 rebounds, 1 steal. As a team, the Highlanders made 20 of 47 shots, including 7 of 23 from 3 point range, for a combined 42% shooting percentage.  While they started slow in the first half at the free throw line, Webster made 20 of 34 free throws (or 58%).

With the win, Webster improved to 4 wins, 0 losses on the season. They next play in the Holiday Tournament Championship game Friday, December 28, 2012, at 6:00 p.m. against the host school Notre Dame Fighting Irish.

The Lady Highlanders also won their opening round game against the Liberty-Harrison Mountaineers by a score of 66 to 44 and they will play in the ladies Tournament Championship game Friday at Notre Dame at 4:00 p.m.

Wednesday, December 26, 2012

DEVELOPING STORY: County in Predicament over Lack of Space for Prosecutor and 911 Center Offices

Added to the problems the Webster County Commission will face in 2013 will be the issue over the lack of adequate office space for both the offices of the Prosecuting Attorney and the offices of the 911 Communications Center and Office of Emergency Services (OES).

This office space predicament has arisen since a hardship exemption previously granted by the West Virginia Ethics Commission will expire in less than 18 months. That exemption allowed Prosecuting Attorney Dwayne Vandevender to receive rent money from the County so that he could continue to operate the Prosecutor's offices out of Vandevender's privately owned office building located at 137 South Main Street in Webster Springs.

Ordinarily, both West Virginia law and an Advisory Opinion by the Ethics Commission makes it both a crime and an ethics violation for elected public officials like Vandevender from entering into contracts (such as a rental lease) with County Commissions in situations where the public official may have some influence or control over the Commission.  

Ethics Advisory Opinion 2006-11 (see link below), issued in September, 2006, specifically stated that a Prosecutor exercises "a voice, influence, or control" over a County Commission since the Prosecutor acts as the statutory lawyer for the Commission. As such, a Prosecutor can not rent out his privately owned office space to the County Commission unless the Ethics Commission grants a hardship exemption.

Even the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals back in 1949 recognized the dangers of a public official entering into contracts with a County Commission. The Court said that: "The purpose of the [law] is to protect public funds, and give official recognition to the fact that a person cannot properly represent the public in transacting business with himself. To permit such conduct would open the door to fraud. The [law] is designed to remove from public officers any and all temptation for personal advantage."

Hardship exemptions have been previously granted at least three times to the Webster County Commission because of the lack of office space either owned by the County or because such space is not readily available to meet the needs of a Prosecutor's office. There is no room in the Courthouse or Courthouse Annex to suit the needs of a Prosecutor's office.

The first hardship exemption issued on July 10, 2008 was granted until January 1, 2010. The full opinion by the Ethics Commission on this exemption can be accessed at this link:
http://www.ethics.wv.gov/SiteCollectionDocuments/PDF%20Contract%20Exemptions/CE%202008-09.pdf
That first exemption was later modified to be a three year exemption, effective until September 5, 2011. The full opinion on this modification can be accessed at this link:
http://www.ethics.wv.gov/SiteCollectionDocuments/PDF%20Contract%20Exemptions/CE%202008-10.pdf

When this three year period was about to expire, the County Commission asked for another three year exemption. The Ethics Commission denied the three year request, but did grant a one year extension effective until January 15, 2012. The full opinion of this one year extension can be accessed at this link:
http://www.ethics.wv.gov/SiteCollectionDocuments/PDF%20Contract%20Exemptions/CE%202011-03.pdf

Recently, the County Commission received another extension effective to July 1, 2014. When it granted this extension, the Ethics Commission noted that the County Commission voted at its February, 2012 meeting to approve a plan to buy land and build a new 911/OES Center, but that it would take about two years to complete that project. As such, the Ethics Commission granted the extension to July 1, 2014. The full opinion of this last extension can be accessed at this link:
http://www.ethics.wv.gov/SiteCollectionDocuments/PDF%20Contract%20Exemptions/CE%202012-01.pdf

While there is still over a year and a half left on the exemption, Vandevender said "it is a pressing problem. They [the Commission] have a lot of work to do to move the 911/OES Center" and that time will expire quickly if they do not act now.

One option being considered is to relocate the Prosecutor's office to the offices of the current 911/OES Center, since that building previously served as a Prosecutor's office when the late E.V. "Jack" Morton, Jr. served as Prosecutor. The County purchased the building in the early 2000's from Morton to house the current 911/OES Center. Obviously, if this option is exercised, a new building for the 911/OES Center would be needed.

The reason this option is being considered is because the 911/OES Center in it current location is antiquated and does not fit the ever evolving needs of a modern 911/OES operation.  911/OES Director Richard Rose recently discussed the problems with the current offices and the possible relocation.

Rose said that the current location is totally out of space, which problem is aggravated any time the County has an emergency, such as twice this year. He said that the technology and equipment space for the 911 center has overwhelmed the offices. Rose also noted that the building is not particularly secure, and that OES equipment is unsecured on the outside premises.

In the video at the end of this article, Rose discusses the options being considered for a new 911/OES Center as well as the costs. He expects a public hearing on these issues in the near future. While he is aware of the office space problems with the Prosecutor's office which might cause a relocation of the Prosecutor's office to the 911/OES offices, Rose said there are independent reasons for building a new 911/OES Center.

Since 2000, when he was first elected as Webster's Prosecutor, Vandevender has used his private office building at 137 South Main Street as the offices of the Prosecuting Attorney. From 2000 until 2008, Vandevender was by law a part-time Prosecutor and he conducted a private practice of law at his office building in addition to using his office as the Prosecutor's office. During this time period, he received no rental money from the County.

In 2008, the law changed making Vandevender a full-time Prosecutor. Since then, Vandevender has continued to operate the Prosecutor's offices out of his private building. The Commission currently pays Vandevender $500.00 per month to cover the added utilities incurred by the operation of the Prosecutor's office. Vandevender said he makes no significant profit from that rental agreement. "I might make $50.00 a month and some months I lose money, depending on the costs of utilities in any month," Vandevender said.

In addition to the Prosecutor's offices, his building leases out space for dentist Kevin Lucky, and Vandevender has three rental units in the building of which he is the landlord. Vandevender said because of his income from those other leases, he does not desire to sell his office building to the County, at least at a price the County could afford considering the value of those additional income generating sources.

To read the full Ethics Advisory Opinion 2006-11, please click on this link:

To read the full WV law allowing a County Commission to seek a hardship exemption from the above ethics opinion, please click on these links:

The video below is part of an interview with OES/911 Director Richard Rose concerning the possible relocation of the OES/911 offices:

Webster County Bar Changes Dramatically

Nearly a century ago, in 1913, these 12 lawyers were members of the Webster
County Bar Association. This photo is believed to have been taken at the old
Webster Springs Hotel once located in Hotel Bottom in Webster Springs. The
1910 U.S. Census listed 9,680 residents in the County, almost identical to the
number of residents in the County in 2012. While the number of residents has
remained the same from a century ago, the number of actively practicing
lawyers in the County has decreased dramatically.
One hundred years ago, the County of Webster had a dozen lawyers listed as members of the County Bar Association.

At the end of 2012, the number of active lawyers has dwindled to just eight, and half of them work for the county or state government. Those in government service include:  Circuit Judge Jack Alsop, Family Court Judge Jeff Hall, Prosecutor Dwayne Vandevender, and Assistant Prosecutor Dara Acord. Lawyers in private practice include: Montie VanNostrand, Howard Blyler, Dan Hardway, and Joyce Helmick Morton.

Of the eight lawyers listed above, one just recently opened a practice of law in Cowen (i.e., Dan Hardway) and three others are moving into semi-retirement. Long time attorney Joyce Morton, of Webster Springs, is taking down her "shingle" in the County, as she will be working for a private trust after the first of the year. Her law partner, Montie VanNostrand, will also be drastically scaling back her Social Security practice. And another long time attorney, Howard Blyler, of Cowen, is also severely curtailing his practice of law as well. 

Except for Hardway, and excluding the four government service lawyers, there are no lawyers in private practice living and working in the County full time. The two judges and two prosecutors can not represent residents in legal matters because of their positions. Residents are forced to turn to out of County lawyers for assistance in light of the lack of general practice lawyers in the County.

Sunday, December 23, 2012

Webster County Unemployment Rate Increases Again


For the third month in a row, the unemployment rate in Webster County increased, now standing at a whopping 13% as of November, 2012, up from the 12.1% October rate.

Once again, Webster County had the second highest unemployment rate in the State, second only to Clay County's 14.1% rate. One year ago, Webster's unemployment rate stood at 11.4%.

Statewide, unemployment dropped to 7.3%.

Full county by county unemployment statistics can be found at this link:
http://www.workforcewv.org/LMI/datarel/cnty_PR.pdf