Under present law, a motorist can not be pulled over by police solely for failing to wear a seat belt.
Today, the House of Delegates passed a bill changing that law so that police can pull over motorists solely for failing to wear a seat belt. The bill now goes to the Senate, which in past years has passed such a new seat belt law.
Friday, March 29, 2013
School Consolidation Battle Heating Up
With the public hearings slated in April, 2013 over the proposed school consolidation plan, the battle is heating up on the legal front.
Readers will recall that previously a letter was sent to the Superintendent pointing out legal deficiencies in the prior plan, which was then withdrawn.
Yet another letter pointing out alleged deficiencies in the current plan was sent to the Board recently.
County Commission Met Regarding Budget Crisis
On Tuesday, the Webster County Commission met in a special session at the Webster County Courthouse in Webster Springs (officially known by its legal charter as the town of Addison, named after Addison McLaughlin), West Virginia.
The Commissioners, including elected Commissioners Chuck Armentrout and Jerry Hamrick, along with appointed Commissioner Daniel Dotson, III, met in the Commission's hearing room, at least one Commissioner appearing by telephone, which room is located in the "old" wing of the Courthouse.
The "old wing" of the Courthouse is the larger wing of the Courthouse which contains the old Courtroom on the second floor, and was rebuilt after the fire of 1888 which destroyed the old wooden Courthouse. When one enters the old wing through the front main entrance, the hearing room where the Commissioners met to discuss the budget crisis is the first room to the left (after going up a small flight of stairs).
Usually, the Commission meets just once per month, during the first of the month, in regular session. The Commission within the past month has met three times regarding the budget for the upcoming fiscal year.
The County operates on a fiscal year, which is different than a calendar year. A calendar year runs from January 1 through December 31 while the County's fiscal year runs from July 1 through the following June 30.
The recent budget meetings dealt with the County's budget for the next fiscal year beginning July 1, 2013.
According to several courthouse sources, the Commission imposed an approximate 11 percent cut in the operating budgets of the offices of the various elected officials. In addition, county employees will be paying a part of their health insurance premiums.
Finally, although there are many more details to be reported, at least some county officials are not happy with the budget decisions, and a potential lawsuit may be on the horizon over the proposed budget cuts.
Wednesday, March 27, 2013
Is this the State of Webster County?
After the first of each new year, the President delivers a "State of the Union Address" and the Governor delivers a "State of the State Address."
What would a "State of Webster County Address" sound like? Please note that while the following "address" was not made by any county official, the facts contained in this "address" are real and the supporting data can be accessed by the links at the end of the "address."
My fellow Webster Countians, I am here to report to you on the state of Webster County. And, sadly, the report is not good.
According to the 2010 United States Census, we have 9,154 people living in the county.
Almost 40% (or 3,627) of our residents receive some form of Social Security or Supplemental Security Income (SSI) benefits. Regular "old age" Social Security recipients total 1,900 persons or 20.7% of our residents. SSI recipients total 802 (or 8.8%) of our residents, and Social Security Disability recipients total another 925 (or 10.1%) of our residents residents. Our near 40% rate is well above the statewide average of 28.7% of residents that receive these types of benefits.
Of our 9,154 residents, only 2,550 are employed. These working folks make up only 27.9% of our total number of residents in the County. Another 430 residents who want to be in the workforce are unemployed. We have the second highest unemployment rate in the State at 14.4%.
The news for our children is likewise not good. According to the most recent data, we have 1,493 students in the County. Almost 72% of our school age children are considered to be "low income," qualifying for the free or reduced lunch program. Statewide, only 51.9% of students qualify as such.
Our graduation rate is 81.69%, slightly lower than the statewide average of 84.34%. Our dropout rate for 2012, however, was at 3.2% (those students in grades 7 to 12 who dropped out and did not enroll elsewhere), much higher than the 2012 statewide average of 1.7%. For the past three years, our dropout rate has been higher than the statewide average.
Let me put some of these numbers into perspective. If we subtract from our total number of 9,154 residents the 3,627 Social Security recipients, the 2,550 working folks, the 430 unemployed folks, and our 1,493 students, we have about 1,054 residents unaccounted for by the public statistics. These 1,054 folks either do not work, are not counted on the unemployment roles, do not draw Social Security, and/or are not students.
Some of the 1,054 are obviously less than school age since the latest Census reported that we have 1,974 people under age 18. Subtracting the 1,493 students from the 1,974 under age 18 category leaves us with about 481 less than school age children.
So, if we take those 481 less than school age kids out of the 1,054 unaccounted for folks, we still have a question about who are the 573 residents who just do not show up in any category.
In February, 2013, at least 210 Webster residents received TANF [temporary aid to needy families] benefits from the West Virginia Department of Health and Human Resources. More shockingly, 2,914 residents received food stamps in February, 2013. Food stamp recipients make up 31.8% of our County's residents.
In February, 2013, at least 210 Webster residents received TANF [temporary aid to needy families] benefits from the West Virginia Department of Health and Human Resources. More shockingly, 2,914 residents received food stamps in February, 2013. Food stamp recipients make up 31.8% of our County's residents.
In any event, these numbers do not speak well for the health of our County.
While crime statistics show a decline for the 2009 through 2011 years, it certainly appears that in the latter part of 2012, and certainly thus far in 2013, crime may be increasing, particularly related to the plague of meth users, sellers, and makers.
Compounding our meth problem, high unemployment, high Social Security recipient rate, and sub-par student dropout, graduation, and low income student rates is the fiscal dilemma now faced by the County. We have operated for the past few years on budget deficits now estimated to be anywhere between $800,000.00 and $1.1 million dollars per year.
The bottom line appears to be that we have a nice place to live in Webster County, but little way to make a living to stay here, and little opportunity for our youth.
The state of our County has room for improvement and one would hope it can only go up.
Social Security data for Webster County can be accessed at these links:
The most recent unemployment data for Webster County can be accessed at this link:
The 2010 United States Census data for Webster County can be accessed at this link (chose West Virginia and areas within being counties, select Webster):
The 2012-13 school enrollment data for Webster County can be accessed at this link:
The dropout rates by County can be accessed at this link:
The graduation rates for Webster County and the State, as well as the percent of low income students in Webster County and the State, can be accessed at this link (see left column data):
More information about the crime statistics and the meth problem can be accessed at these links:
Information about our County budget dilemma can be accessed at these links:
http://webstercommentator.blogspot.com/2013/03/county-employeebenefit-cutbacks-likely.html
Webster County TANF benefit statistics can be accessed at this link:
http://wvdhhr.org/oamr/OAMRReports/SFY2013/TANF/TANF_Feb13.htm
Webster County Food Stamp benefit statistics can be accessed at this link:
http://wvdhhr.org/oamr/OAMRReports/SFY2013/FS/FS_Feb13.htm
Webster County TANF benefit statistics can be accessed at this link:
http://wvdhhr.org/oamr/OAMRReports/SFY2013/TANF/TANF_Feb13.htm
Webster County Food Stamp benefit statistics can be accessed at this link:
http://wvdhhr.org/oamr/OAMRReports/SFY2013/FS/FS_Feb13.htm
This article was not posted to tear down the County or its residents, but rather to point out that we have serious problems that need attention by our legislators, local, state, and federal.
Wolverton Drug Case Argued at Supreme Court Today
The appeal of the delivery of drug convictions of Kathyrn Wolverton and her son Davis Wolverton were heard by the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia today.
If the questions and comments made by the Supreme Court Justices to the Wolverton's attorneys are any indication of the potential result, most spectators of the argument would say that the convictions will likely be upheld.
Gassaway lawyer Daniel Grindo, representing Davis Wolverton, was the first to address the five Justices. He attempted to argue that the conviction should be set aside because the Prosecutor knowingly presented false testimony to the jury. Before he was able to fully explain his position, Grindo was interrupted by Chief Justice Brent Benjamin, who asked "was it false testimony or just inconsistent testimony and what is your proof it is false?"
Grindo claimed the Prosecutor admitted it was false. However, as pointed out by Justice Margaret Workman, "how do we know which statement [that the confidential informant made] was false?" Workman, along with Benjamin and Justice Allen Loughry, all commented that the defense attorneys had the full opportunity at the trial to point out the allegedly false statements and to expose the informant's inconsistent and/or false statements. Justice Workman said "this was an issue of credibility for the jury to determine." Loughry asked "how were you prejudiced since you cross-examined [the informant] and exposed before the jury his inconsistencies?"
Several members of the Court took issue with Grindo's characterization of what the Prosecutor said at the trial to Judge Jack Alsop. The trial transcript, as read by Chief Justice Benjamin, did not support Grindo's characterization that the Prosecutor said the informant's testimony was false.
Grindo also argued that the conviction should be set aside because a husband and wife sat on the jury together. Grindo argued that despite the Court's instructions not to discuss the case, it could not be reasonably expected that a husband and wife would not so discuss the case in a multi-day trial.
Chief Justice Benjamin pointed out that West Virginia has a civil case that did not find any problem with a husband and wife sitting on a jury together. The Chief asked Grindo: "Are you aware of any case from any other State or jurisdiction saying that a husband and wife sitting on a jury together is improper?" Grindo answered: "No."
Sutton lawyer Bernard Mauser, representing Kathryn Wolverton, next addressed the Justices. He only argued the issue of the confidential informant's inconsistent or false testimony, and did not raise the husband/wife juror issue.
Mauser did not appear to fare any better with the Justices than did Grindo. Justice Workman noted that "maybe the informant testified falsely at the abuse and neglect proceeding, maybe he testified falsely at the trial, but it's just a jury issue for the jury to judge the credibility of the witness." Not one of the Justices appeared to accept the argument that the Prosecutor knowingly presented false testimony.
Scott Johnson, Senior Assistant Attorney General, represented the State. He argued that the defendant's due process rights were protected in this case because the informant was subject to "withering cross-examination." He argued the jury was well aware of the informant's inconsistent statements and ruled against the Wolverton's anyway.
On the husband/wife juror issue, Johnson noted that other Courts across the nation which addressed the issue did not find fault with having a husband and wife on a jury together. Not one Justice asked any question or made any comment during Johnson's entire argument.
The case has now been submitted for a written decision. Generally, a written opinion is issued within about 60 days of the oral argument.
For more information about the appeals filed by the Wolverton's, please review our prior article by clicking on this link:
Tuesday, March 26, 2013
Oral Arguments Wednesday at Supreme Court in Wolverton Mother, Son Drug Case
On Wednesday, March 27, 2013, the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia will hear oral arguments in the drug conviction cases of Kathyrn Wolverton and her son, Davis Wolverton.
The Wolverton cases are set as the fourth case to be heard on the Court's docket on Wednesday. The Court begins proceedings at 10:00 a.m. and breaks for lunch at Noon, then resumes again at 1:30 p.m. It is possible that the Wolverton case could be heard prior to the lunch hour, but it may also be heard at 1:30 p.m.
For further details on how to listen in on the arguments live over the Internet, and for details about the appeals filed by the Wolverton's, please review our prior article about these cases by clicking on this link:
http://webstercommentator.blogspot.com/2013/02/wv-supreme-court-to-hear-arguments-on.htmlThe link to the Supreme Court's webcast to hear any of the cases on Wednesday is below:
http://www.courtswv.gov/supreme-court/webcast.html
Update on Past Weekend's Meth Arrests
As previously reported, on Friday, March 22, 2013, Amy Lynn Dodrill, age 25, was booked into the Central Regional Jail on several felony charges.
Warrants for Dodrill's arrest were issued on December 6, 2011, but Dodrill could not be located. Recently, Dodrill was arrested in the State of Florida and law enforcement from Webster County traveled to Florida to pick up Dodrill on the outstanding warrants, and she was subsequently arrested and jailed on the Webster County charges. Bail was set at $300,200.00.
According to the criminal complaint filed against Dodrill by State Police Trooper E.E. Bostic, on November 29, 2011, at 11:45 a.m., Bostic and Senior Trooper P.A. Huff received a recorded statement from Donald Short that on November 24, 2011 Short was at Dodrill's residence at 66 Kessler Lane, Webster Springs, and witnessed Matthew Friend in the back bedroom with a gas mask on "gassing" a meth lab from a tube. Short said Dodrill was present and had knowledge of the activity going on at her residence. Short said he saw the active meth lab and smelled the fumes from the active meth lab.
On November 29, 2011, at 1:30 p.m., Huff secured a search warrant for Dodrill's residence from Magistrate Richard Robertson. At 2:45 p.m., Bostic, Corporeal E.L. Loughridge, and West Virginia Parole Officer C. Bright entered Dodrill's residence and located multiple black plastic bags with trash from several meth labs, including pop bottles with meth leftovers, Drano cleaner, dissected lithium batteries, containers of ice packs, empty Coleman fuel, blister packs from Sudafed, and burnt aluminum foil from smoking meth. Sergeant C.D. Kelly advised there were six labs at the residence.
Dodrill has been charged with six felony counts of Conspiracy to Operate or Attempt to Operate a Clandestine Drug Laboratory, as well as misdemeanor Worthless Check crimes.
Also, as previously reported, three persons were booked into the Central Regional Jail early Sunday morning on meth related charges.
Dylan Lee Canada, age 18, Dustin Wade Perrine, age 18, and Samantha Dora Jean Skidmore, age 18, were each charged with the felony crimes of Operating or Attempting to Operate a Clandestine Drug Laboratory and Conspiracy.
According to the criminal complaints filed against the three by State Police Trooper E.E. Bostic, on March 24, 2013, at 12:15 a.m., Bostic and Trooper S.G. Blake located liquid Drano, lithium batteries, Coleman fuel, salt, and coffee filters at 6 Erbacon Road (Circle Brooke Manor Apartments). Bostic received a recorded statement Canada that he, Perrine, and Skidmore gathered the said meth precursors to operate a Clandestine Drug Laboratory and intended on operating said laboratory once they obtained pseudo ephedrine.
Magistrate Robertson set bail for each of the three at $100,000.00 each.
An arrest is not an indication of a person's guilt, but is merely an allegation made by a law enforcement officer based on probable cause that a person may have committed an offense.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)