Saturday, December 22, 2012

The Letter that Stopped the School Consolidation Plan


DAN HARDWAY LAW OFFICE
DAN L. HARDWAY, J.D. 
ADMITTED IN WV, FL, NC & IN
PO Box 625
6815 Webster Road
Cowen, WV 26206
(304) 402-3036
fax: (919) 341-2331
dan@hardwaylaw.com


December 17, 2012

Sent via U.S. Mail and Electronic Mail
Superintendent Martha Dean
Webster County Board of Education
315 South Main Street
Webster Springs, WV 26288
martha.dean@access.k12.wv.us

RE: School Closing and Consolidation

Dear Superintendent Dean:

This firm has been retained by Save Our School, LaCosta Westfall and Tanya Giles in regard to your proposal to the Webster County School Board to close Diana Elementary School (hereinafter“DES”) and to consolidate 7th and 8th grade students from Glade, Webster Springs and Diana at Webster County High School.

I have reviewed your Webster County Schools School Closure and Reorganization Documentation as Required by State Board Policy 6204 (hereinafter “Documentation”). It is apparent from a review of the Documentation that it does not comply with W.V. Code § 18-5-13a and WVBE Policy 6204. The Documentation does not provide either the Local School Improvement Councils, nor the School Board members, with the necessary information required to make a fair evaluation of the proposal. Due to its failure to comply with state law and WVBE Policies, it does not provide sufficient information upon which the Board members can make a decision without arbitrariness, partiality, passion or a misapprehension of the law.

Specifically, the Documentation, among other deficiencies, has these issues that, at a minimum, need to be addressed in order to comply with Policy 6204 and W.V. Code § 18-5-13a: 

1. The Documentation proposes both a school closure that applies to only one school with either two or three schools accepting the students from the closed school, but it also proposes consolidating the 7th and 8th grade students from two (or possibly three) elementary/middle schools to the high school. As such it proposes two separate actions for Board approval without separating the information and analysis applicable to the two separate proposals so as to enable the proposals to be evaluated independently on their separate merits and detriments. (I am uncertain of the actual number of schools that would accept students from DES if it is closed due to your statements that some of the students may be able to attend Hacker Valley although that option is not addressed in the Documentation. Similarly, you have stated that 7th and 8th grade students from Hacker Valley may elect to attend Webster County High School although, again, that option does not appear to be addressed in the Documentation.)

2. WVBE Policy 6204, at section 2.2.1.e. requires projections of enrollment by grade“in respective attendance area” for the next ten years. Your Documentation does not provide any projected enrollment by grade for the next ten years and does not provide it by grade nor does it provide the information by school which would be necessary to provide the enrollment by respective attendance areas within the county. You have provided a chart of historical enrollment by grade groups and a comparison, county-wide without respective attendance area breakdowns, of projections of attendance variation from actual attendance, for the past ten years. You have not, however,provided any projection of attendance in the effected schools’ respective areas for the next ten years as required by the Policy. Failure to provide this information makes it impossible to evaluate the proposals impact on class sizes, compliance with WVBE Policies 2419, 2510, 2520 and 6200, among other issues.

3. Not having provided projections, you have also not complied with the provisions of Policy 6204 § 2.2.1.d by not utilizing or discussing the Second Month Reports.

4. The maps you have provided at pages 8 and 9 of the Documentation do not provide a legend indicating the student enrollment by grade at effected schools as required by Policy 6204 § 2.2.2.a.A.

5. No physical appraisal of DES, Webster Springs Elementary, Webster Springs Middle School, Webster County High School, and, potentially, Hacker Valley Elementary School was provided in the Documentation. The only information provided in the Documentation is a Facility General Information Worksheet for Glade Middle School which is dated May 10, with no year specified, an undated Site Evaluation Worksheet for Glade Elementary School, and a Building Component Evaluation Worksheet for Glade Elementary School dated May 10, with no year specified. Policy 6204 requires this data to be provided for all schools effected by your proposal and such information is essential to both the citizens of the county and to the members of the Board in order to be able to properly evaluate and understand the impact the proposal will have on Webster County Schools.

6. The Documentation has no information in regard to the various effected schools’adaptability to the “present and proposed educational programs and the provision of related services” as required by § 2.2.2.c.

7. While the Documentation does provide some information on the utilization of DES and Webster Springs Elementary School, it does not provide such information on other effected schools as required by § 2.2.2.d.

8. The Documentation does not provide any information regarding the cost of the consolidation of the 7th and 8th grades at Webster County High School as required by§ 2.2.3.a.A.

9. The Documentation does not provide any information regarding the anticipated costs the plan will require at the receiving schools (Webster Springs Elementary, Webster County High School and, possibly, Hacker Valley Elementary) as required by §2.2.3.a.B.

10. The Documentation does not provide any information by which any reasonable, non-arbitrary person could calculate even a reasonable approximation of the net cost or savings generated by the plan. Policy 6204 § 2.2.3.a.C. requires the Documentation to provide the net cost or savings based upon the information provided in compliance with §§ 2.2.3.a.A and 2.2.3.a.B.

11. The information provided in the Documentation regarding the cost of renovation at Webster County High School is very general and nonspecific. In addition, the Documentation provides no hard data, or even specific proposals of specific renovations, that would allow a true, reasonable and non-arbitrary cost analysis of the needed renovations. With the minimal information provided in the Documentation,it is not possible to determine whether the estimate of $100,000.00 in renovation expenses is reasonable or arbitrary.

12. The Documentation does not address whether the proposed plan will have any effect on the administrative and service personnel at Webster County High School. You have stated publicly that the plan will require at least one additional administrator at Webster County High School. This should be addressed in the Documentation under both the provisions relating to costs and those related to the effect the plan will have on personnel.

13. The Documentation has a summary of the educational program resulting from the plan and a statement of assurance that listed WVBE Policies have been considered and adhered to. The Documentation does not address in any detail whatsoever how the Policies have been considered and how they will be adhered to. There is not a projected educational program improvement analysis as required by § 2.2.6. I would think, at a minimum, such a plan would address how moving all the students from a school that has made AYP with the highest reading and math scores on Westest II reading and math (and one of the highest in the state) to schools that have not met AYP in, respectively, the past two and three years. Consequently, it is not possible to evaluate the validity of the assurance.

14. Finally, you have stated publicly that students from Diana may be allowed to choose to attend Hacker Valley Elementary and that 7th and 8th grade students from Hacker Valley may be allowed to elect to attend Webster County High School. The documentation does not address the effect that such plans may have on transportation and the effects that the plan’s implementation would have on variances § 202.02 of WVBE Policy 6200.

Much of the information required to be provided by the West Virginia School Board’s regulations has not been provided as part of the Documentation required to be available to the public,and provided to the Chairman of the LSICs, at least 30 days in advance of any public hearing as required by Policy 6204 § 2.1. Consequently, I am asking that you voluntarily provide the missing information, and postpone any and all hearings until 30 days after the information is provided, so as to comply with the WVBE regulations.

I note that, while courts in this state are generally reluctant to review school board decisions on closures and consolidations, it is well settled in West Virginia law that a county board’s failure to comply with the WVBE regulations will form a basis for relief in court. See, e.g., McComas v. Bd of Educ. of Fayette County, 475 S.E.2d 280, 197 W.Va. 188 (W.Va., 1996); City of Benwood v. Bd. of Educ., 573 S.E.2d 347, 212 W.Va. 436 (W.Va., 2002).

It is my hope that we can agree to resolve these issues without the necessity of court action so that the hearings you have on the proposed plan may be held before an informed public and an informed School Board. I look forward to hearing from you in regard to the issues I have raised herein.

Very truly yours,
Dan L. Hardway

cc via email: Lacosta Westfall
Tanya Giles
Paula Tanner
Harold Carpenter
Joyce Markle
Lisa Clutter
Heather Davis

Questions Raised About Reviving Webster County School Consolidation Plan

According to multiple sources close to the Webster County Board of Education, in all probability, the school consolidation plan recently withdrawn by Superintendent Martha Dean will be resubmitted in 2013 after legal defects in the plan are corrected.

According to applicable law and regulations, the plan can be resubmitted in the next calendar year, i.e., 2013. When any consolidation plan is proposed, West Virginia Board of Education Policy 6204 requires that the County Board of Education must submit the required information, conduct the required public hearings, and vote on the plan by December 31 of the calendar year prior to the calendar year in which the school closing or consolidation is to be effective.
[Note: a "calendar year" runs from January 1 to December 31 while a "school year" runs from July 1 to the following June 30].

In short, since the plan was recently withdrawn and can not be corrected and voted on by December 31, 2012, Policy 6204 now prohibits any school closing or consolidation prior to December 31, 2013. Under a strict reading of the Policy, a school closing or consolidation could occur beginning on January 1, 2014 if the plan is approved by December 31, 2013.

Even though a school closing or consolidation could occur as early as January 1, 2014 if all of the required actions and vote occurs by December 31, 2013, the same is not likely at all due to a number of other legal impediments.

When the Commentator interviewed Superintendent Dean recently, she indicated that if the plan then being considering was approved by December 31, 2012, the closing and consolidation would not go into effect until the start of the 2013-14 school year. Why? First, the high school can not possibly be renovated in time to include the 7th and 8th graders right after a December 31 vote. Second, many school personnel have legal contracts that stretch over the school year (and not a calendar year).

In short, all probability suggests that if a consolidation plan is approved next year (by December 31, 2013), it will not be effective until the start of the 2014-15 school year.

While many in the Diana area rejoiced over the news that the plan was withdrawn, they also realize that the battle to save their school is far from over. They hope that if the plan is resubmitted that it is resubmitted well in advance of any hearings and vote so that all alternatives can be considered.

West Virginia Board of Education Policy 6204 can be found at this link:
http://wvde.state.wv.us/policies/p6204.pdf
School consolidation/closing laws can be found at this link:
http://www.legis.state.wv.us/wvcode/ChapterEntire.cfm?chap=18&art=5&section=13A#05

Thursday, December 20, 2012

Flashback: Unlucky Deer at Go-Mart


On January 26, 2006, as I was walking from the Prosecutor's office to the Webster Courthouse on Church Street, the whitetail deer in the above picture was spooked by a car driving up the street. The deer proceeded to jump over the fence near the sidewalk and onto the roof of the Go-Mart station. It then made the unwise decision to leap off the roof into the Go-Mart parking lot, breaking three of its four legs in the process. I took this picture and sent it to the Webster Echo. The Echo printed the picture with one of their best headlines.  If I recall correctly, it read: "Deer Finds Go-Mart Inconvenient". City officer Paul Williams later took the deer out of the way and put it out of its misery.

Webster County Child Abuse and Neglect Cases Have Kept the WV Supreme Court Occupied All Year Long

Twelve Webster County child abuse and neglect cases have been decided this year by the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals, and almost all of them have dealt with parents losing their rights because of their drug abuse.

On December 11, 2012, the Commentator reported on five recent cases decided from September through November, 2012 (see link at end of this article). Earlier this year, from January through June, 2012, the Court decided yet another seven child abuse and neglect cases, as summarized below.

First, on January 18, 2012, the Supreme Court upheld the termination of a mother’s parental rights because of her continued drug abuse. This mother failed to acknowledge that she had a substance abuse problem, even after testing positive for marijuana and opiates on four separate occasions after she was given an improvement period by the Circuit Court. This mother even told the Judge that she would not quit using marijuana and “sees nothing wrong with its continued use.” In light of her position, the Court found that there was no reasonable likelihood that the mother would correct the conditions of abuse and neglect (her parenting skills were seriously impaired from the continued drug abuse).

The full opinion of this first case can be accessed at this link:
Second, also on January 18, 2012, the Supreme Court upheld the termination of a psychological father’s rights because of his failure to protect a child with whom he had bonded. In this case, the psychological father allowed the mother to repeatedly use drugs in the presence of the child and allowed the child to have contact with inappropriate persons. Although this psychological father mostly tested negative on his drug screens, a search of his home found a “detox” kit used to mask drug use on drug screens. He defied the Circuit Court’s Order not to allow contact by the mother with the child. Again, the Court found that this psychological parent was no likely to correct the conditions of abuse and neglect found by the Court.

The full opinion of this second case can be accessed at this link:
http://www.courtswv.gov/supreme-court/memo-decisions/spring2012/11-1210memo.pdf

Third, on February 28, 2012, the Supreme Court reversed the Judge’s decision to terminate the parental rights of the mother. The mother in this case was accused of knowing that the father sexually abused their daughter and not protecting the child from that father. The Judge found that both parents were abusive and neglectful in that regard. The West Virginia Department of Health and Human Resources (WV DHHR) recommended that the mother’s custodial rights be terminated.

One of the big issues in this case was whether the Prosecuting Attorney properly followed the recommendations of his client, i.e., the WV DHHR. After questioning by the Judge, the Prosecutor agreed with the Judge that the Judge could terminate the parental (and not just the custodial) rights of the mother.

The Supreme Court found that the Prosecutor did not act inappropriately as he was merely agreeing with the Judge’s interpretation of the law. However, because the WV DHHR did not recommend the termination of parental rights, the Supreme Court reversed the decision, sending the case back to the Judge to reconsider a new case plan for the parties.

The full opinion of this third case can be accessed at this link:

The fourth and fifth cases, decided on March 12, 2012, are separate appeals by a mother and a father who both had their parental rights terminated. This case began when police found drug paraphernalia and items used to create methamphetamine in their home. Many capped and uncapped needles were found in the home. The needles and drugs were readily accessible to the children. Both parents were later convicted of attempting to make meth and were each sentenced to one to three years in prison.

In both of these cases, the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals ruled that:
"In the present matter, there was an abundance of evidence that the children were in danger; the components of a methamphetamine laboratory were found in the home where the children were residing. Petitioner denies that these materials were used for making drugs, but made no explanation for the possession of most of the materials. Moreover, petitioner pled guilty to charges regarding the attempt to operate a methamphetamine laboratory. Furthermore, the testimony of the investigating officers and the DHHR worker showed that there were capped and uncapped needles in the home, and evidence that some of the needles were used. Petitioner Father denies this, but the circuit court determined that his denial was not credible. This Court finds no error in the adjudication or in the termination of parental rights without an improvement period."

The full opinions of both of these fourth and fifth cases can be accessed at this link:
http://www.courtswv.gov/supreme-court/memo-decisions/spring2012/11-1403memo.pdf
http://www.courtswv.gov/supreme-court/memo-decisions/spring2012/11-0774memo.pdf

Sixth, on April 16, 2012, the Court upheld the termination of a father's parental rights because of his substance abuse that was affecting his judgment and ability to properly provide for the children's health, safety, and welfare. The father admitted to snorting prescription pills. Drug paraphernalia was found in his home. After being granted an improvement period, he continued to test positive for drugs. When given the chance to participate in drug abuse counseling and treatment, this father reverted back to continued drug abuse. The Supreme Court found no error in the decision to terminate made by the Circuit Judge, stating that there was no reasonable likelihood that the conditions of abuse or neglect could be corrected in the near future.

The full opinion of this sixth case can be accessed at this link:
http://www.courtswv.gov/supreme-court/memo-decisions/spring2012/11-1237memo.pdf

Seventh, on June 25, 2012, the Court upheld the termination of a mother's parental rights. This mother previously and voluntarily gave up her rights to another child, and she was ordered not to have further contact with convicted felons. She then had another child. The father of the new child was a convicted felon. Under the law, the WV DHHR had a mandatory duty to file this case in light of the prior termination of rights regarding the other child.

The convicted felon father of the new child admitted to drug abuse and his prior convictions for breaking and entering, driving under the influence, and the sale of methamphetamine and cocaine. The Circuit Court allowed the new child to remain with the mother provided she not permit contact with the convicted felon father, or any other felon. She was given a two year rehabilitation period. Less than fourth months into that rehabilitation period, the Circuit Court found that she involved herself with another man who had his own parental rights terminated and who was involved in drugs.

The Supreme Court agreed with the termination of the mother's rights because the mother had been unable to dissociate herself from men who are addicted to drugs and who jeopardize the health, safety, and welfare of both the mother and child. This mother lost her rights because she repeatedly exposed her child to substance abusers.

The full opinion of this seventh case can be accessed at this link:
http://www.courtswv.gov/supreme-court/memo-decisions/spring2012/11-1589memo.pdf

Our prior article about the five recent abuse and neglect cases decided between September and November, 2012 can be accessed at this link:
http://webstercommentator.blogspot.com/2012/12/wv-supreme-court-kept-busy-with-webster.html

Winter Arrives Friday in Full Force

Here is the latest national radar image from Intellicast.com showing the "big picture" of what is approaching on Friday (current as of 10:45 a.m. on December 21, 2012).


Wednesday, December 19, 2012

Highlanders Stay Perfect, Roll Over Roane 70 - 53



Senior forward Hunter Given poured in 27 points, including 17 in the first half, to lead the Webster County Highlanders to a comfortable 70 to 53 win over the Roane County Raiders on Tuesday evening in Spencer.

The game was close at the start, with Webster holding a slim 15 to 14 lead at the end of the first quarter. The Highlanders outscored Roane 25 to 13 in the second quarter, to lead at halftime 40 to 27. Webster edged the Raiders by 2 points in each of the last two quarters for the 17 point win.

After the game, Assistant Coach Eddie Mazzella summed up the game: "This was a big test for us tonight. Roane County has a really good basketball team. Our role players were big. We have Brett Morris and Hunter Given and everybody thinks we'll stop them, but, hey, our role players were big tonight. Hunter Given had a huge game." 

Mazzella praised the efforts of Dalton Davis, Stephen Cogar, and Hunter Williams as some of those role players. "It seemed like everyone we put in the game played well. At one point we had Morris and Given on the bench, and we gained 5 points," he added.

To say that Given had a "huge game" was an understatement. Given made 8 of 12 shot attempts and 11 of 14 free throws. On defense, he had 6 rebounds, 6 steals, and 3 assists. While the Roane defense tried to focus on Morris, Given stole the show. After the game, Given said he "felt good coming into the game" and agreed that Roane's focus on Morris freed him up to score more, which was a "big mistake on their part."

Despite Roane's defensive focus on Morris, Brett contributed 17 points, 3 rebounds, 2 blocked shots, 2 assists, and 2 steals. Rounding out the scoring for Webster were: Cogar, 8 points, 3 rebounds, 2 steals, 2 assists, 1 blocked shot; Williams, 6 points and 2 rebounds; Logan Taylor, 4 points, 1 rebound, 1 steal; Davis, 3 points, 5 rebounds, 2 steals, 1 assist; Tyler Anderson, 3 points and 2 rebounds; and Lance Stout, 2 points, 2 assists, 2 rebounds. Others playing for Webster but not scoring were: Guy Cowger, who had 3 rebounds and 2 assists; Rick Holcomb, 1 blocked shot; Jake Thayer; and Joe Collins.

Webster improved to three wins and no losses for the season. They next travel to Princeton for a two game holiday tournament on December 21 and 22.

Mazzella's junior varsity team suffered their first loss of the season, bowing to the Roane JV team by a score of 64 to 53. The JV's are now 2 wins and 1 loss on the season.

Tuesday, December 18, 2012

BREAKING NEWS: Superintendent Withdraws School Consolidation Plan

Less than 24 hours after the first public meeting, Webster County Superintendent Martha Dean has withdrawn her proposed school consolidation plan due to legal defects in the plan.

At last night's public meeting at the Diana Elementary School, LaCosta Westfall presented Board of Education members and the Superintendent with a letter from her attorney, Dan Hardway of Cowen, West Virginia. The letter pointed out a number of defects in the consolidation plan proposal. After detailing 14 specific deficiencies in the plan, Hardway wrote that:

Much of the information required to be provided by the West Virginia School Board’s regulations has not been provided as part of the Documentation required to be available to the public, and provided to the Chairman of the LSICs, at least 30 days in advance of any public hearing as required by Policy 6204 § 2.1.  Consequently, I am asking that you voluntarily provide the missing information, and postpone any and all hearings until 30 days after the information is provided, so as to comply with the WVBE regulations.  

I note that, while courts in this state are generally reluctant to review school board decisions on closures and consolidations, it is well settled in West Virginia law that a county board’s failure to comply with the WVBE regulations will form a basis for relief in court.  See, e.g., McComas v. Bd of Educ. of Fayette County, 475 S.E.2d 280, 197 W.Va. 188 (W.Va., 1996); City of Benwood v. Bd. of Educ., 573 S.E.2d 347, 212 W.Va. 436 (W.Va., 2002).

It is my hope that we can agree to resolve these issues without the necessity of court action so that the hearings you have on the proposed plan may be held before an informed public and an informed School Board.  I look forward to hearing from you in regard to the issues I have raised herein.

Apparently, legal counsel for the Board has agreed with at least parts of the letter and suggested that the plan be withdrawn. Due to legal time constraints, any further consolidation plan would have to be re-submitted next year.

The Commentator has confirmed that the Superintendent has withdrawn the plan, according to Board Secretary Brenda Knight.

All further public hearings have been cancelled.

The net effect of these fast moving developments is that the Diana school will remain open another year and 7th and 8th graders will remain in their respective schools.

Contacted by telephone, Westfall was elated about the news. "It's like a great burden has been lifted. All we wanted was more time to review [the plan] and to be able to help the Diana school and all schools in the county by researching other financial ways to keep them open," she added.