Monday, December 10, 2012

Hit & Run Driver Damages Visitors Center

The Gallery's window on the left is the same type of window
destroyed by the hit and run driver, which is now covered up
with a temporary wall.
In the early morning hours of Sunday, December 9, 2012, a yet unidentified hit and run driver smashed into the Addison Visitors Center and Gallery on the Main Street side of the building.

In the process of shattering the Gallery's large window and foundation, the driver also destroyed an antique fire hydrant, decorative light pole, outdoor waste basket, and several items which were on sale inside the Gallery. Initial damage estimates exceed $10,000.00. The town of Webster Springs, which owns the building and Gallery, has already constructed a temporary wall to enclose the Gallery.

A large quilt and other goods cover up the inside of the
temporary wall at the Addison Visitors Center.
According to a source close to the investigation, police have a person of interest they will be questioning, although the person (or persons) have not yet been publicly identified. The source also confirmed that police have physical evidence of the hit and run property damage crime. Anyone with additional information can contact the Mayor's office in Webster Springs at (304) 847-5411.



Case Update: Surbaugh Denied Bail

Julia Surbaugh will remain behind bars pending her new trial on murder charges after a hearing last Friday before Circuit Judge Richard Facemire.

After the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals reversed her first degree murder conviction last month and awarded her a new trial, Surbaugh sought to be released from prison on bail while she awaits her new trial date. Surbaugh, age 40, formerly of Webster Springs, testified at last Friday's hearing by closed circuit television from the Lakin Correctional Facility located in West Columbia (Mason County), West Virginia. 

Surbaugh, and her new court appointed lawyer Kevin Hughart of Kanawha County, pleaded with Judge Facemire to release her so that she could be with her children for the holidays. Webster County Prosecutor Dwayne Vandevender opposed the request, arguing that in light of her conviction (although over-turned), she remains a flight risk and should not be released.  Judge Facemire denied bail and granted her lawyer's request to have a period of three months to prepare for the new trial.

WV Supreme Court Upholds Sexual Assault and Incest Convictions for Roger Simmons


In a unanimous decision handed down on November 16, 2012, the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals has upheld the Second Degree Sexual Assault and Incest convictions of Roger D. Simmons, age 54, formerly of Webster County.

Simmons, who remains incarcerated at the Huttonsville Correctional Center, was originally indicted by a Webster County Grand Jury in May, 2001 for 11 counts of First Degree Sexual Assault, 10 counts of Sexual Abuse by a Parent, Guardian, or Custodian, nine counts of Incest, and two counts of Second Degree Sexual Assault. Simmons accepted a plea offer made by Prosecutor Dwayne Vandevender which allowed Simmons to plead guilty to one count of Second Degree Sexual Assault and one count of Incest, with all other counts of the indictment dismissed. 

In September of 2001, Simmons entered his guilty pleas. In February of 2002, Circuit Judge Jack Alsop sentenced Simmons to 10 to 25 years in the penitentiary on the Second Degree Sexual Assault charge and to 5 to 15 years on the Incest charge, with the sentences to run consecutively, for a total effective sentence in prison of not less than 15 years but not more than 40 years.

On January 4, 2001, Simmons was arrested by former Deputy Sheriff Nellie Knight for sexually assaulting his step-daughter, who was age 12 at the time. Both a criminal case and a related child abuse and neglect case were instituted at nearly the same time.  

Although he pleaded guilty to the two felony charges, Simmons challenged his continued incarceration by a post-conviction proceeding known as a "habeas corpus petition." The petition was eventually heard by Judge Alsop, who issued a 33 page opinion denying the grounds alleged by Simmons. He claimed that the child victim made inconsistent statements in the criminal and child abuse and neglect cases. He also alleged that the child recanted the allegations against Simmons, but then later said she was pressured to recant by her mother to help get Simmons out of jail. Simmons also claimed it was error for the Court to consider an apparently incriminating statement he gave to police after he was arrested.

Specifically, he claimed the following errors: "ineffective assistance of counsel; irregularities in arrest; illegal detention prior to arraignment; excessiveness or denial of bail; sufficiency of the evidence; prosecutorial misconduct; constitutional errors in evidentiary rulings; trial court’s refusal of a continuance; the question of actual guilt upon an acceptable guilty plea; the falsification of the transcript of petitioner’s statement to law enforcement following his arrest; involuntary guilty plea; mental competency at the time of the crime; ability to understand the proceedings due to educational level and reading ability; coerced confession; challenges to the composition of the grand jury or its procedure; defects in the indictment; and incompetence at the time of the offense, as opposed to at the time of trial."

In its brief opinion denying Simmons' petition, the Supreme Court found that no substantial questions of law were presented and that no prejudicial error occurred. The Supreme Court adopted Judge Alsop's 33 page opinion as its own opinion in rejecting Simmons' attempt to overturn his guilty plea convictions.

The entire Supreme Court opinion, along with Judge Alsop's 33 page opinion, can be found at this link:

Rainy Day Expected for Webster County

The local weather forecast for Monday, December 10, 2012 calls for rain with a slight chance of snow late this evening.

Saturday, December 8, 2012

Holly River State Park Opens Temporary Office

Here is the official press release from the West Virginia Division of Natural Resources:


            HACKER VALLEY, W.Va. – More than a month after being closed by Superstorm Sandy, Holly River State Park will begin taking calls on Monday, December 3, from a temporary office.  Electric service at Holly River has been interrupted since October 29, when the area was hit by the storm. 

            Although utility service into the main park has not been restored, one state-owned building located in a separate area of the park has restored service.  Part of this building will be converted into a temporary office and information center to serve the public. Park staff has moved the office computer, reservation books, a phone, and other office needs to create a temporary office to serve park patrons, take reservations and answer questions  

            “We have been overwhelmed with emails and calls of concern for Holly River and the employees there,” said Brad Reed, district administrator for West Virginia State Parks.  “We are very pleased to get our general services up and running again and to be able to provide service and communication to our park guests.”

            The temporary phone number until the main park office has full power restoration is 304-493-6559.  The office operating hours will be Monday – Friday, from 8 a.m. until 4 p.m. The email to contact Holly River is hollyriversp@wv.gov. 

            Holly River State Park sustained heavy damage from the storm, perhaps more than any other state park. In five hours, the park was blanketed in 31 inches of heavy, wet snow. The final depth exceeded 36 inches by November 1. Approximately 95 percent of the electric lines fell to the ground and more than 15 power poles were snapped by downed trees and limbs. Two transformers were smashed. To make matters worse, a hill slide covered and created additional blockage to the road to the cabin area.

            Holly River Superintendent Ken McClintic and the park staff extend their gratitude to park patrons and well-wishers for their concern, patience and understanding as storm recovery continues. “Power lines at Holly River are owned by the park system and our restoration efforts are under way,” McClintic said. “Our goal is to be open in the spring.”

            Other state parks heavily damaged with power outages for more than seven days were Blackwater Falls, Cathedral, Babcock, Audra, Carnifex Ferry Battlefield, Twin Falls, and Hawks Nest state parks, along with Coopers Rock and Kanawha state forests.  Other areas also experienced downed trees and power outages for fewer days.  Trail and roadside tree debris clean-up continues at most state parks across West Virginia from both the June dechero and Sandy. An update page was maintained on the state park website with storm damage images.

            Holly River State Park is located in Webster County in Hacker Valley. It is the second largest park in acreage in the West Virginia park system with a total of 8,101 acres. Nestled in a narrow valley, the park is surrounded by heavily forested mountains, some reaching heights of over 2,800 feet. Learn more about Holly River State Park at www.hollyriver.com.

Thursday, December 6, 2012

Superintendent Martha Dean Responds to Questions About Webster County School Consolidation Plan



Webster County Superintendent of Schools Martha Dean sat down with the editors of the Webster Commentator and Webster Echo/Republican on December 6, 2012 to respond to questions about the proposed school consolidation plan.

The interview, conducted at the Board of Education offices in Webster Springs, lasted about an hour. We have condensed the interview to about 35 minutes in the four videos below. We asked a wide range of questions, some of which have already been answered by the documents Dean presented to the Board, and some of which were not answered by those documents. There are certainly more questions that citizens will have at the upcoming public hearings, but we invite you to watch these four videos to learn more about the proposal.

PART ONE:



PART TWO:



PART THREE:



PART FOUR:


Old Coal Fired Furnace Continues to Heat Courthouse

Black coal smoke billows from
the Courthouse each time the
old furnace is fired up.
Most of the Webster County Courthouse in Webster Springs continues to be heated by an old coal-fired furnace, which heats and circulates hot water through a system of radiators throughout the building.

Coal furnace in basement of
the Webster County Courthouse.
According to maintenance technician Randy Hines, the Courthouse uses about four to five loads of coal, at about 17 tons each, throughout a typical year. Coal ash and waste is taken to the landfill in Craigsville as much as twice per week.


Coal ash and waste.

This old system's reliability continues to be tested as it ages. Costs for a new electric heat pump system ranges as high as $125,000.00. The newer, renovated office space on the third floor of the Courthouse is currently heated and cooled by a heat pump system. 


The main, larger portion of the Courthouse was constructed beginning in 1888, and the jail and center sections were completed by the 1920's.
Coal room with new coal.